Agonist (via Melissa and Amanda) reports that "comma" is a dog-whistle code word that Bush used to signal to the Fundies:
The phrase is: "Never put a period where God has put a comma." Which is to say - it ain't over yet, and God may well make it better. So Iraq's bad, but if we trust in God, he'll make it better.
Mark Liberman of Language Log, after a couple of funny riffs on "comma", starts digging into the dog-whistle theory and uncovers the antcecedents here and here.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Whoa. Richard Dawkins appeared on the Hugh Hewitt show. Hewitt, in case you didn't know, is one of those far right radio wingnuts, a lawyer with a blog who defended George W. Bush, the Iraq war, and always sides with religious conservatives in the culture wars.
It's a fairly long interview, and you…
Ever wondered why it's "red states"? Because it's the "red right". And as one of my favourite Australian lyricists has it, this is because of the red right hand:
Take a little walk to the edge of town, go across the tracks
Where the viaduct looms, like a bird of doom as it shifts and cracks…
Certain things that come across one’s desktop, on the internet, are hard to turn away from. Train wrecks, for example. For me, this list includes commentary about grammatical errors and proper language use.
I find this sort of discussion interesting because I’m an anthropologist, and probably also…
When the word "stinker" was bandied about in reviews, I should have known better. Yet at happy hour last Friday, my two gal-pals and I made a date to see a Sunday matinee of Robert Zemickis' Beowulf. My friends, a biologist and a chemist, had taken medieval literature as undergrad electives so…
I think that Gawd ain't gonna make it better until Bush offers up a little sacrifice. Something like shipping off his twin daughters to Fallujah to replace my brother and his son.
I mean, it's not like they're employed or anything.
.
I'm puzzled by the whole comma thing: isn't that a UCC call for tolerance? I wouldn't associate with fundamentalism.
As Mike said, this still doesn't add up. The UCC is the religious LEFT, not the religious right.
And I have no idea what Gracie Allen's religion was, but I'll bet she wasn't a fundie.
You know - maybe it's because I'm a language teacher, but I couldn't understand the puzzlement over that figure of speech. He probably got it from Miss Reading Fool Laura, true, but it seemed clear to me. I don't think it's a dog whistle, because the people he whistles at (how apt that they're dogs) are very fond of periods. And the UCC isn't exactly on their friends list.
On the other hand, Little Lord Pontchartrain did misappropriate "No Child Left Behind."
The fundie catch-phrase, IIRC, is "never put a question mark where God put a period" or something very close.