More on duck phalluses and uteri

Of course, I was not the only one commenting on the recent duck phallus paper. You should check out the other blogospheric responses, e.g., by Carl, PZ, RPM, Grrrl, Laelaps, Neil, Belle, Zuzu, Guru and many others.

Unfortunately, most people link only to each other, or to the press release, or to the NYTimes article. The articles are fine, but they are simplified for the mass audience. If you are a scientist, you should read the original paper to get all the details.

Furthermore, many commenters on blogs have asked some very good questions about the research which remained unanswered, e.g., about the teleological language used in the article, the male bias, the individual variation within species, the season-to-season changes in males, and the appropriateness of the use of terms like "rape" in the context of animal behavior.

There is a place for asking (and answering, if you have the expertise) those questions - at the discussion forum of the paper itself where two good questions have already been asked. Just click here.

Categories

More like this

tags: ducks, birds, phallus, vagina, evolution, reproduction An interesting article was published today by a group led by Patricia Brennan in the open-access journal, PLoS One, about the structural co-evolution of duck phalluses and vaginas. What, you ask? Ducks have phalluses? Yes, indeed they do…
Spring is in the air. The obvious signs are everywhere: the temperature is rising, the flowers are blooming, and everyone's writing about boners. There's this post from Darren Naish on turtle gonads, and Carl Zimmer has an article on duck phalluses (don't call them penises, as Darren explains) in…
A review of evo-devo (Jenner, R.A., Wills, M.A. (2007) The choice of model organisms in evo-devo. Nat Rev Genet. 8:311-314. Epub 2007 Mar 6.) is starting to make rounds on the blogs. I cannot access the paper (I'd like to have it if someone wants to e-mail me the PDF), but the press release (also…
You may be aware that, as of recently, one of my tasks at work is to monitor media coverage of PLoS ONE articles. This is necessary for our own archives and monthly/annual reports, but also so I could highlight some of the best media coverage on the everyONE blog for everyone to see. As PLoS ONE…

Hi Bora! Thanks for the link. Do I get extra credit for linking to the original paper?

There once was a beetle from Davis
Whose aedeagus was so long he was famous...

I noticed that the original article used the term 'forced extra pair copulation' (FEPC) rather than 'rape' - an emotive word the use of which caused quite a storm over on Pharyngula.