Nobel laureates on being young and the future of science - guest post by Lars Fischer

Lars Fischer studied chemistry and now works as a science journalist, blogger at Fischblog and coordinator at the German-language science blogging site (which recently spawned the English-language sister site Lars and I spent a lot of time together at the Lindau Nobel meeting where Lars interviewed me and I asked Lars to provide a guest-post for my blog about the main 'take-home' message he got from the conference:

Richard Feynman was 29 when he finally published his works on quantum electrodynamics. At the age of 22, Charles Darwin first set foot on the Beagle, and Gerhard Ertl started his groundbreaking works on surface catalysis when he was a PhD student. The Nobel laureates I met in Lindau may have been somewhat elderly, but they never hesitated to make clear that age and experience are no prerequisites to great discoveries.

Quite the contrary. One of the main messages that nearly all laureates emphasized in their lectures and discussions was that the real source of innovation in science are young academics. Martin Chalfie, for example, talked at length about the role his PhD students and postdocs played in alerting him to the possibilities of Green Fluorescent Proteins, which eventually earned him a Nobel prize. It was, however, Sir Harold Kroto who said it best:

The Theory of Relativity wasn't invented by him:

i-f5f9130fc919e07233779414ca8c5a8b-Einstein old.jpg

but by him:

i-ca6436322707d202b5d772cbadb44c8e-Einstein young.jpg

Nobel prizes are rarely ever the result of meticulous planning, but usually result from spontaneous ideas, new perspectives and novel approaches. Most came out of left field. That's why Richard Ernst recommended that researchers should develop an interest outside of science - to develop new perspectives.

Young academics should have the right to fail now and then and develop the courage to risk failure in their research. Trail-blazing research doesn't happen by playing it safe. Research, says Aaron Ciechanover, is full of risk, as is life. A message that especially funding agencies should take to heart. Also, authority isn't always right. Sometimes his/her own curiosity leads a researcher to places where established scientists don't see anything worthwhile. Following such unlikely leads may pay off, according to Gerhard Ertl. It's well worth remembering that young Max Planck was - in what turned out to be the biggest misjudgment in the history of science - once told that there was nothing left to discover in physics.

"In practice, science is only limited by the imaginary power of mankind", says Ryoji Noyori. "I am really losing the power of imagination, because of my age. However, our young successors are full of curiosity, passion and persistence." The most interesting people in Lindau really weren't the Nobel laureates, but the young academics that listened intently to their lectures. They will cause scientific revolutions undreamed of, and their achievements will determine how - and if - we all will live in the future.


More like this

When the chemist Wilhelm Ostwald received the Nobel prize for his research on catalysis in 1909 he probably didn't expect that his field of work would still be one of the most important topics in modern chemistry one hundred years later. Nevertheless all three Nobel Prizes in chemistry in the last…
Ask an informed layman what he or she thinks is the greatest science-based industrial discovery or invention of all time and the person will likely name the computer, the transistor, the telephone, the incandescent light or perhaps even the blast furnace. But key as all these inventions were to…
I posted 173 (this is 174th) posts in July. As I was traveling the first half of the month, I scheduled a bunch of quotes and also a bunch of re-posts of the most basic and informative posts about chronobiology for your summer education ;-) The first week of July, I was in Lindau, Germany, at the…
Clean(er) car exhaust, the ability to make fertilizer from nitrogen in the air, and the promise of hydrogen fuel cells are among the practical applications of the surface, or solid state, chemistry methods elucidated by this year's winner, Prof Gerhard Ertl, of Fritz-Haber-Institut der Max-Planck-…

The game theorist and mathematician John F. Nash got his 1994 Nobel prize (I know it's not the "real" one) in economics for the ideas worked out in his 26-pages PhD thesis. He developed these ideas at the age of 21. That's really cool.