Pose A Question

i-df93df7dc151c3e536afe23ca526d420-puzzled-question-mark.gifAbout a year ago the Seed Mothership, sponsored an event that allowed readers to pose questions to their favorite blogger.  Peter and I, before we had the mothership connection, joined up with that event.  You, the readers, presented several insightful questions. 

So once again, I ask you to suggest some questions/topics.  Just put them in the comments and Peter and I will do are best to answer them.  You may want to keep the questions deep sea related or you will be forced to read our ramblings on matters we have no idea about!

More like this

So once again, things are slow and I ask you to suggest some questions/topics.  Just put them in the comments and Peter and I will do are best to answer them.  You may want to keep the questions deep sea related or you will be forced to read our ramblings on matters we have no idea about!
tags: science news, SeedGroup, ScienceBlogs To the best of my knowledge, I have never been the subject of gossip before, probably because I am the most boring person whom you could ever know. However, an e-magazine, Element broke the news today that Scientific Life and several other science blogs…
All the cool kids were doing this particular round of navel-gazing yesterday and the day before, while I was either dreadfully ill and out of commission or somewhat better and working. (Today was also quite full of work stuff.) However, it's not an unimportant set of questions, and possibly you'…
I have tried to avoid too much navel gazing here during the past few months, but a new paper published in the journal Evolution: Education and Outreach by Adam Goldstein has raised the question "Of what use are evolution blogs?" Before we can answer this question, of course, we have to ask "What is…

OK, I'll start.

What's the current take on a deep sea origin of life?

I just finished reading Genesis by Robert Hazen where he discusses some of the hypothesis' pros and cons and how there is something of a divide between the "ventists" and the "Millerites" (or something like that) and was wondering if deep-sea scientists naturally fell into the "ventist" camp.

As an aside, I have been thinking that deep sea vents seem almost too extreme to be the cradle of life. If life did evolve there, how did it ever move away from there? Doesn't leaving the vent areas involve some major environmental changes (e.g. temperature, chemistry, pressure)? I would think that any organism that can survive there would be extremely specialized and therefore be SOL if it ventured too far. But then again, I'm not a deep-sea scientist.

Does an octopus have a medulla oblongata?

Will you perish as a mere desire-ridden terrestrial, or will you endure the rite of 365 points and sublimate yourself as a creature of the ocean?

By Mustafa Mond, FCD (not verified) on 26 Feb 2007 #permalink

There have been several terrestrial mass extinction events. Did those same events cause similar results in the deep sea, or does the deep sea has its own such events. Ok, this is really more of a paleontology question....

Is "tell me a bunch more about Nudibranchs" too general? And if it is, how about info on how deep deep is. What's the deepest point and have we touched down there yet? What's the deepest a human has gone. An unmanned submersible? And a compare those to scale with layers of the earth and the atmosphere.

Are deep seeps located in the deep sea? I don't know at what depths they're usually found, but if they are I have plenty more questions about them.

Thanks for all the great questions. Will start to address them next week.