Motion Illusions: Standstill, Motion-Color Asynchrony, Intersectional Luminance

In the "motion standstill" illusion, a rapidly moving object is perceived as motionless, and yet not blurred. This means that color, depth, and shape are accurately processed while the motion system fails: in fact, subjects are no better at detecting the direction of motion than chance.

At slightly different frequencies than those which elicit standstill, subjects can even be below chance at guessing the direction of motion, indicating motion aliasing (also observed in the wagon wheel illusion).

One hypothesis about the mechanism driving this illusion is that the temporal frequency of motion that induces motion standstill actually matches the frequency with which the motion system samples the visual field. This is similar to an explanation offered of the wagon wheel illusion itself. An alternative interpretation of the wagon wheel illusion - that it reflects "Reichardt" motion detectors in the visual system - would seem inapplicable to motion standstill, potentially making it a good tool for understanding whether the human visual system does indeed have some kind of visual "refresh rate."

(Incidentally, this work is being done by George Sperling, who early in his career discovered iconic memory.)

While (unsuccessfully) looking for an example of this fascinating illusion, I found this great collection of other motion illusions. Give the visual area MT in your temporal lobe a good workout!

My favorites:

Motion Color Asynchrony

Rotational Motion Aftereffect

Intersection Luminance and Plaid Motion

Can you identify the letters visible behind the gray background?

More like this

One of my favorite perceptual illusions isn't actually visual. It's often called the "cutaneous rabbit" illusion1, for reasons that will be apparent in a moment. I stumbled across it when reading a paper by Dennett and Kinsbourne2. Here's their description of the illusion (p. 188): The subject's…
I really do love illusions of all sorts, in large part because they fit nicely into my narrative about the fallibility of human thought, but illusions are also great as windows into the ordinary working of our brains. For example, color afterimages provide direct evidence for opponent-processing…
The neural processing of color, shape, and location appears to be widely separated in the brain, and yet our subjective experience of the world is highly coherent: we perceive colored shapes in particular locations. How do these distributed representation about visual features get brought or "…
The binding problem is one of the great mysteries of modern neuroscience. Briefly, we know from a variety of studies in humans and primates that the specific features of the sensory world -- particularly the visual world -- are broken down into their separate components by the brain to be…

can anybody tell me if relitive motion illusions, such as the kitaoka spinning wheel illusion, have to be on a flat surface or would they work as a tattoo? cheers

While (unsuccessfully) looking for an example of this fascinating illusion,

I don't know if the trick will work for you but I have very often noticed this illusion while in a car:
Giving a quick glance at the wheels of an overtaking car (so that the relative motion of the car is not the predominant motion) I almost always see the wheels stand still for a fraction of second.

By Kevembuangga (not verified) on 21 Sep 2007 #permalink

Hm, that sounds like an example of the wagon wheel illusion, which is a fleeting or unstable visual effect. motion standstill is continuous. of course these phenomena might be related in some deeper way...