What makes a good post?

First off, I think this is a really good post (not this self-referring post, but the post I am about to link to)

Steak Dinner by Alemi at The Virtuosi

In short, this post is about cooking steak and the measurements of the temperature of the meat. Why do I think this is a good post?

  • First, it is just some ordinary everyday event (well, it's not everyday you get steak). The awesomeness just comes from saying "hey, maybe I should plot this temperature data".
  • If the post was just about plotting data, it wouldn't be terrible. But it does something else. It tries to fit this data to some sort of model. In this case correlating the temperature data with changes in oven temperature and opening the oven door and stuff.
  • The post does this in a reasonable amount of space. Not that long posts are bad, but short ones let the reader digest it easily.
  • The physics and the math are essentially at an introductory level. Lots of different types of readers can appreciate this post. But at the same time, more advanced readers could be inspired to think at a deeper level.

Really, I think the best thing about the post is that it shows how to think scientifically. This is how so many experiments start - with "I wonder what would happen if I plot....."

More like this

The Virtuosi: Steak Dinner "I recently got a new digital meat thermometer. My plan was to slowly cook the steak until the internal temperature got to be about 140 degrees Fahrenheit with the oven at 200 degrees, take it out, wrap in tin foil, crank the oven to 500 degrees, stick it back in, and…
Bora/ coturnix over at Science and Politics has generated a lot of conversation via his taxonomy of science blog posts, mostly relating to the call for people to start publishing data and hypotheses on blogs. Much of the discussion that I've seen centers on the question of "scooping" (see, for…
Yesterday's post on applying intro physics concepts to the question of how fast and how long football players might accelerate generated a bunch of comments, several of them claiming that the model I used didn't match real data in the form of race clips and the like. One comment in particular…
While I am still fresh on the Space Jump topic, let me take it to the extreme. Star Trek extreme. SPOILER ALERT But really, is this a spoiler alert if it is from the trailer of a movie that has been out forever? Of course, I talking about the latest Star Trek movie where three guys jump out of a…

Agreed Rhett, I enjoy most of the posts of the Virtuosi and they frequently cause me to contemplate. I don't remember where I heard of their blog, but I immediately added ti to my blog roll.