Dawkins vs. Coyne?

Looks like Richard Dawkins has a new book coming out. It's called The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence For Evolution. I can't wait to read it!

But wait a sec? Didn't Jerry Coyne just write that book? Yes, I believe he did. It was called Why Evolution is True. No subtitle needed; the title pretty much says it all.

BOOK FIGHT!

Dawkins certainly wins round one: Better title. Why Evolution is True sounds like the start of a philosophical discussion. The evidence Coyne meticulously documented is not the reason why evolution is true. It is merely the reason we are confident that evolution is true.

Meanwhile, The Greatest Show on Earth is much catchier and well-captures the excitement of the science. Put the boring stuff about evidence and evolution in the subtitle.

Guess we'll just have to wait and see about the rest...

More like this

A few weeks ago I took notice of a looming book fight between Richard Dawkins' forthcoming The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution and Jerry Coyne's book Why Evolution is True. I gave Round One to Dawkins on the grounds of having a better title. Now Round Two goes to ... Coyne! His…
The other day I sallied forth to the local Barnes and Noble to pick up my copy of Richard Dawkins's new book The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution. As I walked into the store I noticed a person stacking books on the main kiosk. She asked me if I was looking for something in…
Chris Mooney and Sheril Kirshenbaum have another of their New Atheist bashing essays up, this time in The Los Angeles Times. It is, alas, a dreadful piece of work. P. Z. Myers has already wieghed in here, as has Jerry Coyne here. The actual arguments in the op-ed are standard fare: The New…
I was looking for a Hallmark card with that on the cover (and also, preferably, a sad-eyed puppy dog) to send to Josh Rosenau and Chris Mooney, but they didn't have one, so I had to settle for a blog post. Here's the sad puppy, at least. Oh, Internet, you are like a giant greeting card store that…

Any guess if either of these will be suitable to recommend for school libraries in very religious districts? I.e., no overt anti-religious statements that would cause an administrator (high or low) to nix the suggestion?

I should find out soon on Coyne's book, as I should a copy within the week. Dawkin's name is probably toxic even if his book is "clean", so my hope is on Coyne's.

It's even more complicated than that!
Dawkins gave an interview last year when he mentioned he was writing a book about evolution for the general public. He mentioned the title he was intending to use:
"Only a theory."
Unfortunately for Dawkins, Ken Miller released a book with the same title before Dawkins managed to finish.

I am about halfway through Coyne's book. While I find it well written, lucid, entertaining and all that, it just feels as though something is missing. I can't put my finger on it, but it just rings a bit... empty. Maybe it gets 'better'. I got the same feeling reading 'Making of the Fittest.'

Maybe I am being too picky...

Is it wise to liken evolution to a circus?

Any book without "Monty Hall" in the title loses.

My copy of WEIT is due to arrive today! I had to come all the way to England for it tho (on an unrelated trip). Excited to read it!

By Glenn Davey (not verified) on 02 Jun 2009 #permalink

Will Dawkins Mention Matthew and Wells?
It will be interetsing to see if Dawkins will mention these two scientists who Darwin and Wallce both admited got to the idea of natural selection before them.Dawkins has covered up this fact until this year, when he mentioned it at a meeting of the Open University.For more details search Google for "wainwrightscience" and associated link to the Dawkins website,.

Professor Milton Wainwright Dept.Molecular Biology and Biotechnology,University of Sheffield,UK

By Prof.milton Wa… (not verified) on 02 Jun 2009 #permalink

This rings up some awesome points for Coyne: do a search on -
"jerry coyne" botfly

By Bayesian Bouff… (not verified) on 03 Jun 2009 #permalink

Not to mention the fact that Dawkins has already sold millions of books. Not that this makes his book better, it will however, sell more.

I believe this is the book for which Dawkins earned a very hefty advance for from Simon and Schuster. Ironically, his publisher - the Free Press imprint of Simon and Schuster - also publishes Michael Behe's "Darwin's Black Box" and "The Edge of Evolution".

By John Kwok (not verified) on 05 Jun 2009 #permalink

I have a question Is propensity to be religious an evolutionary trait? Is propensity to believe, to have faith an evolutionary trait?

If we were all blind and only one man claimed to have seen this thing he and only himself refers to as light, how would science go about to verify of refute this one man's claims.

By Andrew Njeru (not verified) on 16 Jun 2009 #permalink