What sorts of people

In Shakespeare's The Tempest, Act V scene 1, Miranda says

O, wonder!

How many goodly creatures are there here!

How beauteous mankind is! O brave new world,

That has such people in't!

The third line gave Aldous Huxley the title of his future dystopia, Brave New World. Somewhere between Miranda's naive optimism and Huxley's sardonic pessimism lies What sorts of people should there be? a venture by Canadian academics to investigate the effects of the modern world on our sense of self and "to address concerns around human variation, normalcy, and enhancement". They also have a blog. It is run by the illustrious and lustrously hirsute Rob Wilson, an Australian philosopher in exile at the University of Alberta.

Since we're discussing philosophical blogging, go check out the 69th Philosophers' Carnival at Possibly Philosophy. And Sciblings Jason Rosenhouse and James Hrynyshyn get stuck into the incoherent blatherings of David Brooks in the New York Times, in which he seems to argue that we are abandoning the "materialist" view of the mind in favour of a new respect for "spiritual" states (an assertion contrary to all the research I know, at any rate).

More like this

O, wonder! How many goodly creatures are there here! How beauteous mankind is! O brave new world, That has such people in't! The Tempest is not only one of Shakespeare last plays, but arguably his most profound. No longer content with mere comedy or historical tragedy, he explores the changes…
Welcome to Philosophers' Carnival #32, a monthly blogospheric showcase of philosophical musings. As you wander through the exhibit tents, experience the wonders created by minds with time to ponder (and keyboards with which to capture that pondering). Please remember that unused game tickets are…
No, not that Huxley, the other Huxley. No, not that one either, the OTHER Huxley. OK, yeah, this one: Brave New World Aldous Huxley's profoundly important classic of world literature, Brave New World is a searching vision of an unequal, technologically-advanced future where humans are genetically…
Via Twitter, PalMD wondered if I'd seen this brief item on the New York Times Idea of the Day blog. Writing in The Philosophers' Magazine, Brooke Lewis says tallies of full-time faculty at top American and British colleges show women make up less than a fifth of philosophy departments in Britain…

I wasn't aware 'scientists' had gotten rid of the idea of free will in the first place, let alone that we are inherantly fair or empathic. Does this man have children? Because just on an unjusticied anecdotal note, children very much seem to learn fairness, while 'mine' comes inherantly.

I feel slightly 'straw-manned'...
(Can I verb that? Its all the rage to go around verbing things)

I don't know why anyone thinks there's any problem with verbing things. I certainly don't ... as long as you don't do it so often that your writing becomes a whole blungtrop of neologisms. Are there any real arguments against it?

There's the argument from nounification.

By John S. Wilkins (not verified) on 21 May 2008 #permalink