Responses to the undead gods

My piece, Why the gods will not be defeated, has generated some response on the internet. Reihan Salam & Ross Douthat both have some thoughts, while fellow ScienceBlogger Jonah Leher offered some kind words. Also, just an FYI, I've been asked to turn the post into an extended essay elsewhere. Wait a few weeks for the notification when it goes up. Regular readers won't find anything new, but it will have all of my baroque ideas cheek by jowl in one sequence of text, we'll see how it works out....

PS: Some have taken to criticizing the specific numbers in some of the surveys. Sample enough surveys and you can find almost any number. The point wasn't one specific number, but the general picture the data gives us (and the data tends to converge upon some modal values).

Tags

More like this

The other day I commented on an article by Peter Bancel and Roger Nelson that reported evidence that "the coherent attention or emotional response of large populations" can affect the output of quantum-mechanical random number generators. I was pretty dismissive of the article; in fact elsewhere I…
If there were ever a post to elude a specific category here on ScienceBlogs, this would be it. If it were simply a "hey, I'm back from the mountains" post, I could stick it under "Chatter". But sometimes, visiting remote regions, like mist shrouded mountains or vast, dry swaths of blowing sand can…
Having just returned from a long trip where I gave three talks, one of the first things I saw when I started following social media closely again was this post on how to do better presentations. The advice is the usual stuff-- more images, less text, don't read your slides, and for God's sake,…
An interesting little saga. WUWT had a post up as An interesting issue with ice core data. That's a link to the webcitation, beacuse as of now the post has been removed from WUWT, on the grounds that it was utter drivel. Which is correct - it was. Pretty well the whole thing was error, but for…

Just an essay? You could turn this into a *book*. Seriously. One of my former professors with a keen interest in biology and cognitive science wanted to write a book going into religion along these lines, but felt he couldn't do the science end of it well enough to do it justice.

Really, this is quite good. Let's just say more ammunition against the mysterians amongst my fellow grad students. I really wish I could do this kind of work myself, but I've always been better with details than big picture thinking.

By Spike Gomes (not verified) on 02 Jun 2007 #permalink