Over at my other blog Herrick posts a response to 10 questions for Gregory Clark. Clark is an economic historian whose most recent book Farwell to Alms is making a splash. I read the book recently, but because I'm not well versed in economics I've held off saying much. I will add that Clark's point that the typical humans of 1800 were poorer and less well off than those of 10,000 BCE is an important insight, and it is born out by decades of analysis of remains which show that farmers are on average underfed and nutrient deprived vis-a-vis hunter-gatherers.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
I'm 5 feet 8 inches tall. 1.73 meters. In the United States that's somewhat on the short side, most of the charts suggest I'm around the 30th percentile for white men. Of course, I'm not white. In any case, though I'm on the short side for the typical American male, I'm a giant in my family.…
As I gave a nod to statistical tricks and subtle shell games very recently, the material I review subsequently should be viewed with skepticism and caution. A few days ago I also pointed to a paper which describes and models intergenerational transfers of wealth across various societies. In other…
History tends to make even the most unlikely revolutions seem inevitable. Looking backwards to the 18th century, it's easy to conclude that the Industrial Revolution was bound to happen, that the forward march of modernity was predestined.
But what this fatalistic view of history overlooks is just…
A few days ago I pointed to a paper, Stature, Mortality, and Life History among Indigenous Populations of the Andaman Islands, 1871-1986. It looks at the specific case of the Andaman Islanders to explore the general phenomenon of "pygmy" populations, especially among "Negritos." The Andaman…
What a fascinating treatise. One wonders what Clark makes of the current U.S. situation where American college graduates with every socio-economic edge are displaced by Ukrainian and other third-world graduates, and many can't even find their closest public library on a map.
You can (and many do) blame generations of public school conditioning; is that the whole answer?
One wonders what Clark makes of the current U.S. situation where American college graduates with every socio-economic edge are displaced by Ukrainian and other third-world graduates, and many can't even find their closest public library on a map.
college is the new high school. sort of.
That's exactly my point. Is it the schools, is it parents, is it social expectations, is it TV and video games, is it the mass of immigrants dragging down school populations? Ask, and you'll get many answers.
John Taylor Gatto says, like Clark, that school writing by teenagers in 1910 was more erudite than that of today. Certainly, I've seen samples of that, but he doesn't fully subtract the effects of the offset produced by the reality that in those days it was a very select population whose kids were in school at 14.