1. gregladen
  2. Californial Prop 8 Struck Down by Scotus

Californial Prop 8 Struck Down by Scotus

By gregladen on June 26, 2013.

From Mercury News:

In a ruling that assures further legal battles, the high court found that backers of Proposition 8 did not have the legal right to defend the voter-approved gay marriage ban in place of the governor and attorney general, who have refused to press appeals of a federal judge's 2010 ruling finding the law unconstitutional.

It was a 5-4 decision, usual suspects.

Reminder: Who is on the Supreme Court matters.

Reminder: Who is in the White House matters to who is on the Supreme Court.

Reminder: Which party controls the Senate matters to the ability of whomever is in the White House to determine who is on the Supreme Court.

Reminder: The Senate has boneheaded rules so the above reminder isn’t just about a majority, but about a “supermajority” of 60/100.

Reminder: The Republicans want to restrict marriage, what you do in your bedroom, and reproductive rights of women. The Democrats don’t.

Reminder: Party politics is important, ignore that at your peril.

Tags
Uncategorized
prop 8
same sex marriage
SCOTUS

More like this

"DOMA is unconstitutional as a deprivation of the equal liberty of persons"
The Supreme Court of the United States has truck down the so-called "Defense of Marriage Act" as unconstitutional. It was a 5-4 decision. A ruling on California Prop 8 is expected soon. From NPR: Section 3 of the law defines marriage as "a legal union between one man and one woman as husband and…
Worth Reading: Hobby Lobby edition
A few of the recent pieces I’ve found worth bookmarking about the Supreme Court’s Hobby Lobby decision: Dahlia Lithwick and Sonja West at Slate: Quick Change Justice: While you were sleeping, Hobby Lobby just got so much worse “To prove that the Affordable Care Act’s contraceptive mandate was not…
Supreme Court Refuses to hear Gay Adoption Case
I am very disappointed to report that the Supreme Court has refused the cert petition in Lofton, the case that seeks to overturn the Florida ban on adoption by gay individuals or couples. They will not hear the case, which leaves the appeals court ruling that upheld the law in place. This does not…
Two Quick Thoughts About the Prop Eight Ruling
By now you have no doubt heard that a federal judge in California has struck down Proposition Eight, a voter referendum that outlawed gay marriage. Go here for a quick summary of the basic facts. I have not had a chance yet to read the entire decision, and I do not intend to attempt a legal…

You couldn't find an up to date picture of the SCOTUS?
A petty complaint maybe, but I love Sonia Sotomayor.

Nitpick: The prop 8 ruling wasn't exactly the usual suspects as Scalia and Roberts joined Kagan, Breyer and Ginsburg in the majority. The DOMA ruling was more like the usual, with Kennedy joining the liberal side.

By Nick Theodorakis (not verified) on 26 Jun 2013 #permalink

Hey STUPID. It was not struck down. Simply instructions sent to VACATING the last appeal with instructions to dismiss the motion for the appeal. How STUPID are you?

Essentially, the SCOTUS ruled that the plaintiffs did not have the standing to appeal former District Judge Walker's ruling which said that denial of same sex marriage was unconstitutional. They did not, repeat did not uphold Walkers ruling. Subsequently, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals which had issued an injunction holding up Walker's ruling until the SCOTUS ruled, dissolved the injunction and same sex marriage started up again in California. the Prop 8 proponents filed a motion to the SCOTUS demanding that the injunction be reinstated until the SCOTUS decision became final. The motion was denied by Justice Kennedy.