Hippos and Pezosiren: Walking Under the Water


Hippopotamus amphibius, photographed at the Philadelphia Zoo.

ResearchBlogging.org Have you ever tried to walk along the bottom of a pool while fully submerged? It isn't easy. Keeping your feet on the bottom is enough of a task, and you would probably need a weight belt to take an underwater stroll. Hippos (Hippopotamus amphibius), though, walk and even prance along the bottom of lakes and rivers with ease. How do they do it?

When compared to a whale or even a manatee (the latter of which I will address a bit later on) a hippo does not look especially well-adapted to life in the water. It has a low, squat body and lacks a broad tail, flippers, or any other broad surface to help propel itself through the water. Neither is this amphibious mammal well-suited to quick movements on land. Hippos can trot a bit, but they are so cumbersome that while walking on dry land they always keep three of their feet in contact with the ground at a time.

A hippo walking on land

The hippo is obviously a cumbersome animal, but it is not just because of their tubby physique. Parts of the appendicular skeleton of hippos are osteosclerotic, meaning that their bones are extraordinarily dense due to the replacement of porous bone with more compact bone. (Hippos have extra, lighter bone material in the large medullary cavities within their limb bones, too.) This means that their bones act as a kind of ballast to help them achieve neutral buoyancy underwater. Without this added weight they would have to actively expend a lot of energy to remain underwater (and, conversely, too much "bone ballast" would make it harder to surface when they needed to come up for air).

This adaptation to aquatic life allows hippos to exhibit a greater range of locomotion under the water than on land. Since they do not have to actively hold themselves down, and the watery environment buoys them up, they can walk, prance, and even "fly" underwater. This range of movement was recently described by biologists Brittany Coughlin and Frank Fish in the Journal of Mammalogy after observing the two female hippos kept at Adventure Aquarium in Camden, New Jersey.*

*[As a side note, these individual hippos often harass and even attempt to eat the birds kept within the enclosure. Many captive birds have died from stress as a result. This raises questions about the ethics of attempting to create a "natural" setting for aggressive animals in zoos and aquariums.]

A hippo moving underwater. Note how it uses minimal movement of its forelimbs to push off from the bottom.

Unfortunately the size of the hippo enclosure and the amount of time selected for study limited the observational data, but Coughlin and Fish still recorded 102 sequences of hippos moving underwater (of which 32 were selected for analysis). The hippos did not perform their full locomotive repertoire, but they did often walk by the viewing window along the pool bottom. When they did so they moved in a sort of slow-motion gallop with only one foot (vs. three on land) in contact with the ground at any one time. It almost goes without saying that the hippos would not be able to move the same way on land as they did underwater.


A restoration of Pezosiren The bones in grey represent parts of the skeleton that were recovered. From Domning (2001).

Could Pezosiren, an Eocene relative of modern manatees from the rock of Jamaica and described by D.P. Domnig in 2001, have moved in a similar fashion? Today manatees and their relatives within the Sirenia are adapted to a fully aquatic lifestyle; their forefeet are stubby flippers, they lack hindlimbs, and they propel themselves with up-and-down oscillations of their broad tails. Like whales, however, sirenians evolved from terrestrial ancestors, and Pezosiren is a startling creature that helps illustrate how sirenians became adapted to aquatic life.

If you only saw the skull of Pezosiren you might be fooled into thinking it was a fully aquatic form like modern sirenians. While it's skull differs in some subtle ways, it is easily identifiable at first glance as being a relative of manatees and dugongs. The strange thing is, however, that Pezosiren had four limbs and almost certainly was an amphibious creature. It could still walk on land and did not have the swimming adaptations seen in its later relatives.

Indeed, Pezosiren looked very hippo-like. It was short and barrel-bodied, and it also had osteoslerotic bones. This was not an animal that was just dipping its toes into the water but one that was already semi-aquatic. There is little doubt that it was spending considerable time in an aquatic environment. I do not know of any studies seeking to reconstruct the locomotion of this animal, but it would seem a fair inference to suggest that while its movements would be restricted on land it would have exhibited a wider range of movements under the water. It may have moved in ways analogous to, but not exactly like, the hippos studied by Coughlin and Fish.

For more on aquatic mammals see:

Coughlin, B., & Fish, F. (2009). Hippopotamus Underwater Locomotion: Reduced-Gravity Movements for a Massive Mammal Journal of Mammalogy, 90 (3), 675-679 DOI: 10.1644/08-MAMM-A-279R.1

Domning, D. (2001). The earliest known fully quadrupedal sirenian Nature, 413 (6856), 625-627 DOI: 10.1038/35098072

More like this

A beautiful artistic reconstruction of Indohyus by Carl Buell.During the last 30 years paleontologists have uncovered a startling amount of fossil evidence which has illuminated the early evolution of whales. The earliest members of the cetacea looked nothing like the marine mammals we are familiar…
I don't have time for anything at the moment, it's terrible. So here's this, from one of my talks on marine mammal diversity and evolution... For more on Pezosiren portelli, see Domning (2001); the diagram contrasting the prorastomid, protosirenid and crown-sirenian is from Domning (2000). The…
The extinct whale Dorudon, from the new PLoS One paper.When the English anatomist William H. Flower proposed that whales had evolved from terrestrial ungulates in 1883 he cast doubt upon the notion that the direct ancestors of early whales chiefly used their limbs for swimming. If they did, Flower…
The big news in this week's issue of Nature was the discovery of a small ornithischian dinosaur covered in bristles, but there was another, shorter paper that caught my eye. In December 2007 Nature printed a short communication on Indohyus, a small artiodactyl that seemed like a good candidate for…

Pretty cool. Heavier bones would permit retention of more air in the lungs and therefore longer aerobic dives.

By Sven DiMilo (not verified) on 13 Jul 2009 #permalink

Prett cool! I would like to notify Santa Clause that instead of a pony when I was 8, I wanted one of these! Way cooler and more fun!

I've never known much about hippos. Thank you for the lesson!

I'm curious about Sven's comment. You'll have to pardon my lame question as I'm just learning about how things work in bodies. How do heavier bones permit more retention of air?

This is great, particularly the juxtaposition of terrestrial and aquatic motion. Who'd have thunk hippos could be so graceful and frivolous under water? I've only ever seen pictures of them standing still. The bone part is especially interesting, because birds' bones are also adaptive, in the opposite direction. I'd love to learn about the genes involved, and whether they're the same ones. In reply to Grace's question: air is less dense than water, so if it's trapped in your lungs, it increases your buoyancy, and you tend to rise toward the water surface. But if you have especially dense bones, they can counteract the buoyancy of the air, and hold you down.

I do not know of any studies seeking to reconstruct the locomotion of this animal

I don't think there's any right now.

Pezosiren might have done the hippo-like walk when on the bottom, but, it also - based on the morphology of the vertebral column - seems to have been able to swim in an otter-like fashion.

Grace: I think it's a buoyancy issue. If the bones are working as ballast, then having heavier bones means you can hold more air in the lungs while still being able to submerge fully and stay in contact with the riverbed for walking. Denser bones allow the animal to accomplish this without needing to be larger overall.

What I hadn't appreciated until looking at the video links just now is how LONG hippo bodies are in proportion to the length of their legs. Overall hippo proportions look closer than I had thought to those of (reconstructed) Pezosiren.

By Allen Hazen (not verified) on 14 Jul 2009 #permalink