When Republican Ideology Collides with Reality: The Abortion Edition

Before I get to two videos of Democratic congresswomen talking about abortion and birth control, something that Adam Serwer wrote is very germane:

These videos are striking because they're a reminder of how little of media coverage of political battles over abortion reflects the views of real human beings, as opposed to the reductive, paternalist caricatures that seem to dominate the conversation.

Anyway, here's Democratic congresswoman Jackie Speier:

And Democratic congresswoman ties together the importance of birth control and poverty:

As regular readers know well, one of the things I regularly cover is education policy. After watching Rep. Moore's speech, how can teachers unions be the primary stumbling block for poor children--which is where the educational crisis lies.

I'll also add it's good to hear an elected official talk about what it's like to be poor as opposed to talking about poverty in the abstract.

After hearing these two women, I tempted to think we should just boot all the men out of Congress: we're just too unrealistic.

More like this

In 2005, my first widely republished article was entitled "Peak Oil is a Women's Issue" and detailed the ways that material realities for women were likely to change in an energy depleted world. I got more than a 100 emails after I wrote that piece, mostly falling into two camps - either "Wow, I…
Boyish good looks - the next generation of sexy? Men like Mike Rowe on the outs? I couldn't help but notice that a new study has come out about the behavioral effects of hormonal contraception. It's all over the science news sites. With titles ranging from the conservative "Pill May Change…
Having tired of hearing all of the mindless blathering about "judicial activism", the right wing catchphrase that means "judges refusing to allow us to do whatever we want to other people", I hereby propose a new phrase: legislative activism. In response to unpopular court opinions, particularly…
On the 31st of October we will officially reach 7 billion people on the earth. Over the next week or two we'll be talking a lot about population issues, and I wanted to start by doing a light revision of an article I wrote some years ago about a concept a lot of people don't grasp very well - the…

Republican ideology never collides with reality - its parallel and thus they never meet.

I would say that Republican ideology isn't parallel with reality; it's SKEWED from reality. It will never collide, but it looks more and more distant from reality as time goes on.

By mercurianferret (not verified) on 26 Feb 2011 #permalink

My father did legal abortions. I helped my father do legal abortions. The pro-lifers used to picket and threaten him at his clinic in an effort to "protect life".

When women were not allowed to receive legal abortions, they found ways to do it themselves. The OB-Gyn wards used to have a separate unit for those women who came in with botched back street abortions that caused bleeding and sepsis. Many women died or lost their ability to have children at a later time. I remember the story of a young woman who died of sepsis from an illegal abortion; the doctors lied to her parents about how she died ("an unusual virus")because it would have been too shameful for the family at the time.

The Repugs are just pushing malignant cultural and religious memeplexes to their idiotic, non-reality based, base in an attempt to maintain power. Women and girls will be vulnerable and suffer if they are not effectively countered with reality and real stories.