Kalathomyrmex: New Genus, Old Species

Kalathomyrmex emeryi, Argentina.

Kalathomyrmex emeryi (Forel 1907), Argentina.

In Zootaxa last week, Christiana Klingenberg and Beto Brandão introduced to the world an entirely new genus of fungus-growing ant, Kalathomyrmex.  Yet the single species, K. emeryi, is a widespread neotropical insect that has been known for over a century.  In fact, I photographed it twice during my recent trip to Argentina.  How does this happen, a new genus devoid of novel species?

The answer is understandable in light of the distinct pattern of evolution among the fungus growing ants, revealed in a 2008 study by Ted Schultz and Sean Brady:

Simplified phylogeny of the attini, from Schultz & Brady 2008

The history of the attine ants is marked by a series of innovations.  Ants associate with fungus.  Ants develop specialized relations with different types of fungus. Ants start to harvest live vegetation. Ants develop  morphological worker subcastes.  And so on.

At each change, the novel trait is accompanied by morphological alterations.  The renovated lineages possessing the new traits evolve away from the older forms.  It's a delightful evolutionary tale.  Yet it's also the perfect storm to foment a taxonomist's nightmare: morphologically distinct groups that are not each other's closest relatives but instead the residue of lineages that simply never acquired the new adaptations.

Consequently many of the existing attine genera- Mycetophylax, Mycetosoritis, Cyphomyrmex, Trachymyrmex- are not natural groupings but artifacts of evolution.  The leftovers, as it were.

nest

The small entrance mound of a K. emeryi nest in a sandy road.

Bringing attine taxonomy into accord with the phylogeny will not be an easy task.  It will necessarily entail finding characters among groups of markedly similar ants.  Klingenberg & Brandão's paper is the first salvo in the effort: they've tackled the forms previously included in Mycetophylax. 

Kalathomyrmex was erected to house the oldest lineage in the disorderly phylogenetic splatter that was Mycetophylax and comprises a single species, emeryi, first described by the Swiss myrmecologist Forel.  It is defined by a pattern of clypeal setae not shared by the others.  Not the most obvious character, but it does seem to work.

side

Stronger than you: a K. emeryi worker performs nest maintenance.

K & B also resurrected an older genus, Paramycetophylax, for the rare Argentinian ant P. bruchi.  Mycetophylax in the strict sense now includes only a smattering of species that nest in the sand along Brazil's coastlines and rivers, as well as a species or two that had been waylaid in Cyphomyrmex for a few decades.  With any luck this new scheme, firmly rooted in phylogeny, will herald a new era of stability for the taxonomy of fungus-growing ants.

Incidentally, I've discovered that I should never leave the computer for more than a week, ever again. The sheer volume of new ant research during my absence will be impossible to catch up with, much less blog about.

Source: Klingenberg, K., Brandao, C. R. F. 2009. Revision of the fungus-growing ant genera Mycetophylax Emery and Paramycetophylax Kusnezov rev. stat., and description of Kalathomyrmex n. gen. (Formicidae: Myrmicinae: Attini). Zootaxa 2052: 1-31.

More like this

Mycocepurus smithi, in the fungus garden An exciting week for ant aficionados! A new study by ant phylogenetics gurus Ted Schultz and Seán Brady provides the first detailed picture of attine evolution. These New World ants have long attracted the attention of biologists because they, like our…
Lachnomyrmex amazonicus - Feitosa and Brandão 2008 The new world tropics continue to be a rich source of species discovery.  Today's issue of Zootaxa contains a monograph by Rodrigo Feitosa and Beto Brandão revising the ant genus Lachnomyrmex, a small yet delightfully wrinkled group of soil-…
By request, I have now organized the ant photos by subfamily.  This mimics the arrangement from the old site.  For the smug-muggers out there who want to know how it works, I basically set up an "old journal" gallery and put the genus names and links into the caption box.  I used CSS to set all…
Another year passes.  The economy is in the toilet.  Violence spreads in the middle east.  In these trying times, one question must weigh on the minds of concerned citizens: "What's happening in world of ant science?" Of course.  Here are the myrmecological highlights of 2008: The Demise of…

It could be that your absence causes the flood of new research and that if you don't leave your computer from time to time myrmecology will grind to a halt.

Wonderful blog and pictures.

By Mike from Ottawa (not verified) on 04 Apr 2009 #permalink

Just what I was looking for! I was using the KLINGENBERGâ thesis for my ants determinations.

I found three in La Pampa, Argentina:

Mycetophylax morschi (Emery, 1887)

Kalathomyrmex emeryi (Forel, 1907)

Paramycetophylax bruchi (Santschi, 1916)

I saw other post that you were here⦠the next say me and I can accompany you in your campaign.

Best regard

Justo lo que buscaba! Estaba usando la tesis doctoral de KLINGENBERG para mis determinaciones.

Encontré tres en La Pampa, Argentina:

Mycetophylax morschi (Emery, 1887)

Kalathomyrmex emeryi (Forel, 1907)

Paramycetophylax bruchi (Santschi, 1916)

Vi en tus post que estuviste por aquÃ, la próxima dime y te acompaño en tu campaña.

Saludos cordiales,

Rodrigo

I am desperately looking for fresh material of Paramycetophylax bruchi. The previous poster, Rodrigo Tizón, mentions he has collected these. Rodrigo, would it be possible for you to send me alcohol-preserved specimens? I would be INCREDIBLY grateful! You can contact me at schultzt[at]si.edu

I need to add this species to the attine phylogeny described above!

Thanks!

Ted Schultz

Hola, a quienes postearon antes, yo coleccione Paramycetophylax bruchi de todas las castas en Chubut, zona arida, y me gustaria saber actualmente si el genero se sinonimizo o aun se amntiene, es que mi material bibliografico es viejo y muy pobre, aun asi, sigo juntando datos, agradeceria intercambiar informacion con alguien.

By Patricio Moujan (not verified) on 02 Mar 2010 #permalink

you may post more pictures and diagrams to make us understand better.