Carnivalia, and an open thread

I'm taking a little downtime from the busy con fun-and-games, and catching up with the various carnival announcements.

I'm here in Michigan for several more hours, then I'm off to the airport for the late flight home. Talk among yourselves.

More like this

While the conference site is down and before the new one is built, I need, for myself, a list of blog carnivals I follow, so here I am putting it here for my own reference (let me know if I am missing a delightful and useful carnival - if you manage one of them, make sure I am on your mailing list…
I'm on an airplane on my way to Washington DC, for an event sponsored by Americans United for Separation of Church and State. It should be good — I've heard that Blue Gal, D-Cup, Phil Plait, and some of the gang from Corrente will be there…and we'll find out who else. I'll report back later! Until…
Since there's more to the world than Cephalopodmas, here are some refuges if you get tired of my giddy squiddiness. Skeptics' Circle: the Sagan celebration! Four Stone Hearth #3 Animalcules Carnival of the Feminists #29 Carnival of the Liberals #28 Friday Ark #118 Talk among…
The Four Stone Hearth #28 is up on Hot Cup Of Joe Tangled Bank #93 is up on From Archaea to Zeaxanthol Skeptics' Circle #74: The Evolution of Thanksgiving is up on Med Journal Watch Carnival of The Liberals #52 is up on Yikes! Carnival of Education #146 is up on NYC Educator

Several ID/creationist groups have recently begun to invoke Haldane's Dilemma as a problem for the standard biological theory of human evolution. Basically, Haldane's dilemma posits that given a sexually reproducing population, there has been time for only about 1,667 beneficial mutations to be fixed in the human population (for this at least they will conceed that humans and chimps diverged approximately 5 million years ago).
I think their general point is that surely we must differ from chimps by more than 1,667 naturally selected, beneficial mutations. Keeping in mind that chimps have been evolving away from us at approximately the same speed, this leads to something like a maximum of 3,200 genes that could have been differentially selected between us in the past 5 million years. This is approximately 10% of the genome, which seems like plenty of difference to me. Just one change in 150 million nucleotides in my model organism is enough to completely FUBAR it. Am I missing something, or is this just another case of IDiots being idiots?

I have a hypothesis that I'd like to see researched, at least by a search of the literature on brain function and brain trauma. The observation is that singing makes both halves of the brain work together, one side very roughly supplying the tune and the other the words. Recovery from brain injury sometimes involves the other side of the brain taking over some functions from the side that is damaged. So my question is, do people who sing a lot recover more quickly from strokes or concussions that damage the left side (verbal side) of the brain? If there is such a benefit, does it extend to people who are highly musical but don't sing, e.g. pianists? What about people who use the right side in other ways, e. g. sculptors?

University of Dallas drops bid for W library

IRVING, Texas - The University of Dallas withdrew its bid for George W. Bush's presidential library Monday, citing the library site selection committee's exclusive talks with nearby Southern Methodist University.
...
"Our decision to withdraw from the selection process is not a loss for our university; this is not a failure. Instead, we think this is a tremendous success story for us," President Frank Lazarus said.
...

I could agree with that.

I think their general point is that surely we must differ from chimps by more than 1,667 naturally selected, beneficial mutations.

Being used to their own, they're misundreshtmatin all the other chimps.

By David Marjanović (not verified) on 22 Jan 2007 #permalink

I think their general point is that surely we must differ from chimps by more than 1,667 naturally selected, beneficial mutations.

Being used to their own, they're misundreshtmatin all the other chimps.

By David Marjanović (not verified) on 22 Jan 2007 #permalink