Einstein and Millikan

In the previous post, I promised to say something more about Einstein and the photoelectric effect. It turns out that I already wrote about this, back in 2005. That post is the end of a long chain of links about the history of photons.

This is a good thing, because it frees me from having to try to type a new post with a baby on my lap. You're kind of getting short-changed, though, so to make up for the lack of new content, here's a relevant footnote from Chapter 1 of the book-in-progress:

Millikan thought the Einstein model lacked "any sort of satisfactory theoretical foundation," and described its success as "purely empirical," which is pretty nasty by physics standards. Ironically, those quotes are from the first paragraph of the paper in which he conclusively confirms the predictions of the theory (R.A. Millikan, Physical Review 7, 18 (1916)).

And now, back to baby duty.

More like this

A couple of weeks ago, io9 ran a piece about the old accusations that Robert Millikan manipulated his data for the electron charge with the headlineDid a Case of Scientific Misconduct Win the Nobel Prize for Physics? that got a lot of attention. I wasn't as impressed with this as a lot of other…
I spent most of yesterday helping out with an on-campus workshop for high school teachers and students. Seven high school physics teachers and seventeen high school students spent the day doing a half-dozen experiments to measure various physical constants. I was in charge of having them measure…
In the ongoing string theory comment thread (which, by the way, I'm really happy to see), "Who" steps off first to ask an interesting question:One way to give operational meaning to a theory being predictive in the sense of being empirically testable is to ask What future experimental result would…
Yesterday's historical physics poll was about precision measurements. Who were those people, and why are they worth knowing about? As usual, we'll do these in reverse order of popularity... First up is Ole Rømer, a Danish astronomer who is no stranger to this blog, having been profiled as part of…

Man I miss journal access.