Young Faculty ISO Mentoring

Back when I started my Ph.D., I thought I really needed a good mentor that would help me get solidly grounded in my field, get started on a good research project, and get funded. As I got farther along, I didn't want a mentor - I just wanted to do my work and be left alone. Then when I was ready to write my first paper, I really needed that mentor again to look over my early, painful drafts and help me mold the paper into something ready for submission. When I became a post-doc, I felt like I had out-grown a lot of the need for a mentor - I could get funded, do the work, and write papers - I didn't need anyone's help!

But now that I'm a first-year faculty member, I need a mentor again. It feels a bit like saying "I want my mommy!" but I could really use some advice.

I'd like someone that can answer my questions, who can help me work through issues, and whom I can trust to respect my confidences without looking at me as a needy child. I want help figuring out what level of research productivity is really expected at Mystery U and how I should strategize my ideas and time to reach that level. I'd like someone to tell me how things really work in the department and the university - which receptions I can skip and which topics are verboten in casual conversations. It would be great if a mentor could explain what this mysterious "service" thing is and how much of what I should be undertaking in these first few years. A mentor could calm me down when my students score poorly on their first midterm (they did) and help me strategize ways to maintain my high testing standards without having students drop in droves. A mentor would be invaluable in helping me learn to mentor my own graduate students.

Ideally, my mentor should be someone who works in a close enough field that they can make meaningful comments when I am weighing Project A versus Project B. But my mentor shouldn't be the person in the department whom I am most likely to collaborate with - I want that relationship to be less of a junior-senior dynamic and more of a two colleagues dynamic. For me it's important that my mentor be someone who is involved with his own young family, so that he understands the constraints on my time and doesn't perpetually advise that I just need to be working longer hours at the office.

I'm not naïve enough to think that I am going to find a single person who can be my mentor all aspects of my career - I'm not sure that would be healthy. And I've realized that despite assurances from the chair upon my arrival, there will be no formal assignment of a mentor in my department. The university does have a mentoring program, and though my mentor's research area is quite different from mine, in other respects we are quite well matched. I've also found a faculty member in my department who has been very helpful on teaching related issues. And last week I met a woman in a related department who offered to listen if I ever needed someone to talk to - she was even cool enough to mention that there aren't a lot of women -ologists around and that she was happy to talk about "feminine issues" if the need arose. I'd really like to identify a tenured faculty member in my department that can be my mentor in terms of graduate student related issues and research activities.

But I am starting to assemble a network of mentors. Maybe in a few years (after tenure?), I'll feel like I've once again out grown the need for a mentor, but I suspect that I'll never really outgrow the need for wise advice from those who are ahead of me on the path of life.

More like this

Laura Helmuth has written what I think is one of the most important posts so far to emerge from the fray that is Bora Zivkovic's: Don’t Be a Creep: Lessons from the latest terrible, sad, fascinating scandal in the science blogging world. Before getting to what I think is the most important part of…
One of the evergreen topics for academic magazines like Inside Higher Ed and The Chronicle of Higher Education is faculty "mentoring." It's rare for a week to go by without at least one lengthy essay on the topic, many of which recirculate multiple times through my various social media channels.…
ScienceWoman has a great post on balancing responsibilities in a new tenure track job, with an eye to publishing papers and setting up a robust and productive research program. It's a must-read, especially for those who are lucky enough to be starting tenure track gigs in the fall. Since I'm…
I probably should have noticed the warning signs about my graduate program earlier---like, in the first week, when I went to meet my temporary assigned advisor and he said "Oh, uh, I don't want any more students right now. Go find yourself another advisor." (I guess he didn't really understand…

Hi there. Nice site! I'm not a woman in science, but as a new father I'm struggling for that balance that we all seek. At least those of us who aren't science monks or nuns. Keep up the good blogging!

SW, I am consistently impressed by your insight into what you need to do to succeed as an academic scientist. I wish I had you for a mentor!

I really enjoy your writing -- thanks. As a side note, your RSS feed isn't working.

Hi Chris - balance is sure elusive. Janet at Ethics in Science says that juggling is a more apt metaphor.

ScienceMama - I dunno. Most of the time I feel like I have no idea what I am doing! But I guess I was lucky to grow up in an academic household, so my mom can provide advice (even if it is sometimes outdated).

Liz - Yeah. The RSS feed is a technical issue. The Scienceblogs people are working on it. I'll post as soon as I know the feed is working. In the meantime, keep checking back.

Hi Sciencewoman,

I've followed you here from blogger.

Boy there are a lot of new people in the comments. It's like visiting a party with a college friend in another town where you don't know anyone.

Minor point - the page takes longer to load here, as it's a bit fancy schmancier, but the quality makes it worth staying! That said, I rather liked the Minnow pic.

Best wishes!

Hey ScienceWoman,

I would say, go ahead and post some of those dilemmas you need mentoring on right here. You clearly already have a great network going among your blog readers, and I'm sure even old geeks like me can learn a lot by the discussions that ensue. More power to all the ScienceWomen (and ScienceMen)!

By guppygeek (not verified) on 27 Sep 2007 #permalink

Rachel: Thanks for following me. I'm hoping that if my RSS feed here ever gets fixed, I'll see more of my regulars (my old friends) again, but that some of the new readers will stick around too and that soon it'll be like we've all been together forever. And don't worry, I'm pretty sure minnow will be gracing the banner once again. I've got a picture in mind, but it's just so hard to get her to pose. :)

Guppygeek: I fully intend to post some of my questions here. In fact, I'm writing a post right now.

Hi there! i'm new around, and i like Scienceblogs pretty much. Mom is a science teacher. I'm a musician, and will soon be a licensed school teacher, and i've had to dive through recent musical-neuro-research for my final paper. It's always amazing for me that many gender issues do have a biological reason, and i see it in the classroom everyday, so it's always a good thing to check a woman's point of view.

About your need for a mentor... i think it's great you tell the world a Ph.D needs some advice sometimes, like any human.