Ask Ethan: Do 234 Sun-Like Stars Show Evidence For Aliens? (Synopsis)

"This isn't my life anymore, Mulder. I'm done chasing monsters in the dark." -Dana Scully, X-files

One of the most exciting things a scientist can experience is when they look at a sample of data, expecting to not see a particular exciting effect, and yet, something’s there. Immediately, you have to check yourself: what are all the other things it could be? What are the mundane possibilities that could mimic that effect? And what can I do, if anything, to rule them out? Whenever you have a new idea, your main job, first and foremost, is to try and blow the biggest holes in it you possibly can.

The Sloan Digital Sky Survey telescope. Image credit: David Kirkby. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey telescope. Image credit: David Kirkby.

Last week, a publication came out claiming that, out of 2.5 million SDSS spectra that were analyzed, about 0.01% of them showed an unusual high-frequency variation. After exhausting the astrophysical possibilities for this effect, two scientists came to the conclusion that it must be aliens; that no other possibility sufficed. And yet, despite passing peer review, that’s not at all the opinion of a majority (or even a reasonable minority) of scientists.

An artist's impression of sunset as seen from an alien world. Image credit: ESO/L. Calçada. An artist's impression of sunset as seen from an alien world. Image credit: ESO/L. Calçada.

What’s going on here? Find out about these unusual 234 stars -- and what they do-and-don’t tell us -- for this week’s Ask Ethan!

More like this

"Trying to understand the way nature works involves a most terrible test of human reasoning ability. It involves subtle trickery, beautiful tightropes of logic on which one has to walk in order not to make a mistake in predicting what will happen." -Richard Feynman If you were to send a space probe…
“Try to imagine what it will be like to go to sleep and never wake up… now try to imagine what it was like to wake up having never gone to sleep.” -Alan Watts Neutron star matter is the stuff of legends: it's the densest three-dimensional material to exist in our Universe. With a density some 10^22…
"We have chased away the clouds, the sky is all 'rose.'" -Francois Hollande When you have a light curve with two different large, periodic dips in it, a binary star system is the likeliest explanation. The stars eclipse, and in the case where they're so close their envelopes touch, they're known as…
"This event marks the culmination of many years of hard work on behalf of all involved." -Jane Bachynski If you want to take an ideal image of the Universe, you need to not only minimize your light pollution, cloud cover and build the largest-aperture telescope you can, you also need to take away…