1. tfk
  2. "Kick up the fire, and let the flames break loose"

"Kick up the fire, and let the flames break loose"

By tfk on November 14, 2006.

Philip Larkin started a poem that way, but it's good advice for the Forest Service, too. We've long known that fire plays an important role in maintaining forests, prairies and other natural ecosystems.

A new set of studies show that thinning forests without burning makes subsequent fires more dangerous:

Thinning forests without also burning accumulated brush and deadwood may increase forest fire damage rather than reduce it, researchers at the Forest Service reported in two recent studies.

The findings cast doubt on how effective some of the thinning done under President Bush’s Healthy Forests Initiative will be at preventing fires if the forests are not also burned.

Fires feed on the layer of duff that builds up on forest floors, and thinning makes it easier for oxygen to get to a fire. Regular burning reduces the levels of duff, so that the fires are less intense. That means they kill fewer trees and are easier to control in populated areas.

Federal policy since 2003 has pushed thinning of forests as the major tool of forest management, and de-emphasized prescribed fires. It was claimed that regular thinning could control fire frequency and intensity, but it appears that the "healthy forests" plan is probably making them less healthy.

Tags
biology
ecology

More like this

Whispers from the Ghosting Trees
Whispers from the Ghosting Trees A guest post by Gail Zawacki, who blogs at Wit's End. While we hustle busily through the necessities of our lives, wrapped up in our daily preoccupations - our obligations to our families, our jobs, and our dreams - at the same time all around the world, trees are…
Unrest in the forest, trouble with the trees
Yet another study undermines the seemingly obvious concept that trees are inherently good for what ails the planet, climate-wise. Carbon-offset vendors take note: you could be making things worse. They're still needed in the Amazon, of course, but not so much in Ontario. Tom Gower et al write in…
The Forests Behind the Fires
Today's guest blogger is Prof. Dan Yakir. Until recently, Yakir was head of the Environmental Sciences and Energy Research Department at the Institute, and he heads the Yatir Forest research station, which monitors, among other things, carbon exchange in a man-made semi-arid pine forest. This…
Saving the Northwest Spotted Owl
tags: northern spotted owl, barred owl, old growth forests, logging Nothern Spotted Owl, Strix occidentalis caurina. Image: HRF [larger] Despite the fact that President Clinton set aside 7 million acres of forest for owl habitat, the northern spotted owl population is still peril. So the…

This stuff is just like global warming. It's news that those in the industry have known for a long time. New studies confirm that older studies have shown. But in our denial-of-science frame of mind, how long will it take before these facts become obvious?