The anatomy of nonsense

DaveScot, the semiliterate sycophant who used to administer Bill Dembski's ID blog, is in a tizzy. In addition to being an evolution denier, DS is a climate change denier and a promoter of medical woo, you see, and he thinks there's evidence that "[James] Hansen’s former boss at NASA declares himself an AGW skeptic." He is sure that:

The video below is U.S. Senator James Inhofe describing the letter he received from former NASA supervisor and senior atmospheric scientist Dr. John S. Theon

But no! As Tim Lambert points out, and as any fully literate person could tell from the email DS himself reproduced, Theon is not and never was the supervisor of James Hansen. Hansen, of course, is the NASA climate scientist who brought the dangers of climate change to the public attention in the '80s, and remains one of the most powerful advocates for urgent action.

In the email DS quotes, Theon explains that he was "in effect, Hansen’s supervisor because I had to justify his funding, allocate his resources, and evaluate his results. I did not have the authority to give him his annual performance evaluation." As Gavin Schmidt, a climate scientist who works in and with NASA's climate science team, explains, "He was not Hansen's 'boss' (the director of GISS reports to the director of GSFC, who reports to the NASA Administrator)."

Theon's only involvement with Hansen was as a paper-pusher at NASA, responsible for budgeting and accounting, not as a scientific colleague or reviewer. His opinion on climate change is not rooted in any particular expertise in global climate modeling, nor does he actually cite any scientific basis for his claims. He's spouting off, and as long as he says the things that denialists want to hear, they'll keep dishonestly touting him

More like this

The usual denialists (e.g. The Register) are excited because some guy they never heard of before has joined Inhofe's merry band, writing: "I appreciate the opportunity to add my name to those who disagree that global warming is man made." M. J. Murphy has some information about Theon. It seems…
Nowadays I seem to rely on wikipedia for my news stories. Not necessarily for the truth, but that something has occurred. So this little thread at global warming piqued my interest (note, BTW, how the poor dear septics don't even bother trying to edit the page any more, having been crushed so often…
Previously, I've noted the major hole that the IPCC digs itself by releasing its consensus reports on Fridays, only to be lost in the weekend news cycle. Back in February, the timing of the IPCC report helped contribute to what I described as a "massive communication failure" in generating wider…
Well, folks, Andy Revkin has done it again. Previously I have written about how Revkin has basically broken every major story about abuses of climate science, and climate scientists, by the Bush administration. And I must say, it's quite a litany of abuses. That's why I'm glad that so many bloggers…

Perhaps Davey's cheesy poofs at teh Floating Command Center are running low and he's on edge. Or more likely, Davey is a screaming ranting loon that just can't help but get behind every nutter cause he runs across while surfin' the intertubes.

Dave - No, that circus clown is NOT out to get you. Remove your head from Bill Dembski's behind, take your meds or some more DCA and calm down!

Well I work in legislation which has nothing to do with accounts....but believe me...the guys in accounts know the funny stuff we're up to all of the time - its an organic relationship - I'm sure it happens in all government agencies including NASA!

Climate change is happening! Its always happened!

By Foney Farker (not verified) on 02 Feb 2009 #permalink