Purest naïveté and the most mighty understanding

Goethe ... is a wonderful instance of the fact that the purest naïveté and the most mighty understanding can go hand in hand. -Thomas Mann on Goethe.

When I read this, it struck me as extraordinarily insightful. Perhaps, I am taking Mann out of content, but I shall talk anyway. Aren't those who pursue science to understand the world this way too - naïve but with a heart that holds the laws of the world? One could think Einstein may have been naïve when he wrote letters to President Roosevelt on the Manhattan project, but, that was not because he did not understand. Was it? It was because he had a mighty understanding.

By extension, someone's cleverness is not a sign of understanding. This is a sobering thought. All one can hope for is to be able to choose naïveté and understanding whenever cunning and misunderstanding seduce us.

More like this

I really hate this. I really hate having to take a friend to task, but he leaves me little choice. You see, I actually like Chris Mooney. Back in the day, I even even hoisted a pint with him at the Toledo Lounge in D.C., round about the time of the commencement of the whole "framing" kerfuffle that…
Here's one example, unintentionally brought to you by NY Times columnist Frank Rich, of how writing political narratives instead of discussing data leads to unsupported conclusions (italics mine): The continued political import of Iraq could be found in three different polls in the past six weeks…
Over at Anthropology.net Emanuel Lusca has a post, Science As A Human Practice. I sniped a little in the comments, to which Emanuel responded: My intention was not to refine, clarify, or elevate science. My intention was to point out that science should not be put on a pedestal, that it is like any…
Elisabeth Montegna is quite a prolific blogger, with SECular Thoughts being just one of her virtual spaces. We finally got to meet at the second Science Blogging Conference in January and took a tour of the Museum of Natural Science in Raleigh together. Welcome to A Blog Around The Clock. Would…