Repost - Leading edge localization?

I'm gone camping. Late last week I preprogrammed my blog to repost all these entries on microscopy. Enjoy!

I read far too many papers where the author claims that their favorite protein "localizes to the leading edge in migrating cells". Then they show a pretty picture like this one:

i-b9e195e57508464e82a77437c4823c6c-dextran.jpg

The problem is that the cell thickens right at the leading edge. So if your protein is freely floating around, there will ALWAYS be more of it (in absolute terms) at the leading edge then in the nearby lamella. To underline this point, the image above is of fluorescent dextran microinjected into the cytoplasm of a fibroblast. Dextran is a molecule that is certainly not a marker of the leading edge. Here's another example for you, it's a FLAG tagged mitochondrial protein. Notice that some of the tag is not in the mitos - the tag probably got cleaved off before the protein was inserted. Where does this tag seem to end up? You guessed it.

i-3f26abe97283ff73b2e32c0c2f399e78-mito.jpg

So how do you show that your favorite protein is at the leading edge?

Controls folks, they're called controls.

So how to proceed?

You need to label a free floating protein to measure the thickness of the cell (or to control for the thickness of the cell). Take a picture of this free floating protein (we'll call it BS protein or BSP) and of your favorite protein (YFP) in the same cell. Then calculate the ratio of YFP/BSP in the lamella and in the leading edge. If the ratio increases as you move from the lamella to the leading edge, then you can safely conclude that your protein is enriched in the front of the cell. If not? Well then your protein is certainly not enriched at the leading edge, it's probably just free floating in the cell.

(end rant)

For more on the mysterious leading edge and cell motility, see this entry.

More like this

... don't bet on it! I read far too many papers where the author claims that their favorite protein "localizes to the leading edge in migrating cells". Then they show a pretty picture like this one: The problem is that the cell thickens right at the leading edge. So if your protein is freely…
This is for cell motility aficionados. How do cells crawl? Well most in the field would say that actin polymerization generated by the Arp2/3 complex at the leading edge acts to generate an actin meshwork (see pic). The addition of actin monomers right under the membrane (arrows) act as a…
From the Nobel site: 8 October 2008 The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for 2008 jointly to Osamu Shimomura, Marine Biological Laboratory (MBL), Woods Hole, MA, USA and Boston University Medical School, MA, USA, Martin Chalfie, Columbia University…
I gave lab meeting yesterday and I'm exhausted. Here something I presented. (First the images then the explanation) Image 1: Image 2: Signal sequences are short stretches of protein that are recognized by the signal recognition particle and direct the protein to be inserted into the endoplsmic…

Gah!!! Yes, yes, a thousand times yes. It's particularly bad when someone publishes a fluorescent probe that localizes to membranes and then makes the claim that *clearly* the whatever-it-is is localized to the leading edge. You're looking at two fat layers of membrane squashed into the same focal plane, people!

Not that this makes it easy when you are actually trying to find real l.e. localization, but thank you for pointing this out again.

A little bit of microscopy knowledge is indeed a dangerous thing.