Beautiful Evidence: Science Cinema

To scientists, "experimental" is a technical word, one with a precise meaning: that which relates to a procedure of methodical trial and error, to a systematic test for determining the nature of reality. I got in trouble on this blog once, with commenters, for using the word "experimental" too flippantly.

But artists experiment too, of course. Their method of inquiry is different, free from the rigidity that characterizes the scientific method. Artistic experiments are designed to be singular; they aren't supposed to be repeated. They have no control variables. Often, even the hypothesis itself is left undefined. It might seem that when artists use the word "experiment," they're missing the point entirely. And yet, the underlying spirit is the same. An experiment is learning by doing. Seeing what happens. Trying something new, in the hope that from within the noise will arise a form, idea, or emotion that might in itself be repeatable.

The uncanny thing about art in its experiments is that the same results can be achieved through different means. We can be moved by an inexhaustible list of things, depending on how and where we look. The results can't be analyzed systematically. Instead they slowly unfold, although rarely with grace, within each individual.

Science, like art, is a process by which we study the behavior of the physical world through observation and experimentation. There are no strictures in this definition that absolve science from needing to be creative, or playful; in fact a creative approach to science often breeds important results unachievable through strictly empirical means. At the same time, artistic practice often benefits from a systematic process borrowed from the scientific method; many artists create constraints for themselves, with the aim of circling around an idea until its essence is reached.

Search, discovery, wonder, creativity, trial, error, none are reserved solely for either art or science. Simply, the "Eureka!" moment happens to everyone.

It's in this spirit of open-ended discovery that I curated Beautiful Evidence, a one-night experimental science cinema at the historic Hollywood Theatre in Portland, Oregon. The films of Beautiful Evidence range from the baroque black-and-white deep sea documentaries of French surrealist Jean Painlevé (who lived by the credo "science is fiction") to time-lapse light experiments by Al Jarnow and a journey into the insect kingdom by Stan Brackhage, with a healthy dose of dreamlike space vistas in between.

The term "Beautiful Evidence" is borrowed from the statistician Edward Tufte, whose book of the same name explores how science and art both practice a form of focused "seeing" that generates empirical information. All the films demonstrate precisely this kind of seeing-which-turns-into-showing, in which artists mold the raw visual information of the world, employing film as a method of inquiry, performing a rogue, kinetic science of their own design. Ultimately, these efforts reveal fragments of fundamental truth.

If you're in the Portland area, I encourage you to come and behold these strange, non-experimental experiments. Local performers Jeffrey Jerusalem and Golden Retriever will be performing live scores along with the films, which will be sure to lend a dreamy, aleatoric cast to the evening. The show begins at eight p.m. this Saturday, July 28th, and is part of the Hollywood Theatre's excellent Sound & Vision series.

More like this

In my recent WSJ article on age and creativity, I didn't have space to discuss the fascinating research of David Galenson, an economist at the University of Chicago who brings together a vast array of evidence to better understand the nature of creative production over time. Galenson divides…
Magnetic Movie Semiconductor (Ruth Jarman and Joseph Gerhardt) Last fall I stopped by the Hirshhorn Museum's Black Box theatre to watch a short film by Semiconductor (the artistic team of Ruth Jarman and Joseph Gerhardt). Magnetic Movie is a color-drenched, imaginative tour of Berkeley's Space…
Check out the newest events at the Exploratorium. They Sound Great! Dr. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (Flow/Optimal Experience Researcher) Among Renowned Speakers To Appear Mind Lecture Series Continues February 2, 9, and 23, 2008 "Flow" (Optimal Experience) researcher Dr. Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi (…
Have you recently assessed how your students relate to science? I clearly remember when I was young watching old movies and television shows that depicted scientists as older men with glasses, crazy white hair, and lab coats. Have today's students' images of science changed? What about artists? Do…