The system has failed. My point is that the system, as we have constructed it, is a failed one. All kids choose "treat." None choose "trick." Not one. It is time to change course. It is time to cut and run from the Trick-Or-Treat option. That's my only point. We're a one-party system when it comes down to candy distribution.
Furthermore, it would seem more important at this point to get on with the taxonomy scheme project well underway, the one following from that dominant "treat" selection.
Have at it.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Reposted from Halloween 2006.
Since Ben shared his family's taxonomy of candy types, and it's Friday, after all, I thought I'd share some of things that we do with candy around our house and describe some fun things that you can do with candy at home.
Materials and methods. First, you need some…
As several of my fellow science-bloggers pointed out, William Dembski has written a post at Uncommon Descent extolling an "international coalition of non-religious ID scientists", and wondering how us nasty darwinists are going to deal with them.
Alas for poor Bill. I'm forced to wonder: is there…
Kevin Drum and Aaron Carroll report on a new study of the effect of new grocery stores opening in "food deserts" in poor neighborhood. The study is paywalled, so I can't speak to the whole thing, but both of them quote similar bits making the same point: no statistically significant effects on the…
Last week I had a visit from a friend of mine, who was on something of a farewell tour. After several years of planning, he'd packed in his dependable but much-begrudged corporate job, and was setting sail for Asia, to see more of the world. He's already seen much more of the world than most…
In the kid-on-the-porch / adult-in-the-doorway interaction typical of Halloween, it is the kid who offers the choice "Trick or treat!" and the adult who chooses. True, most adults choose to offer a treat. But the choice is made by the adult, not the child.
I see two possible reasons here. 1) the cost of suffering the trick is potentially much higher than the cost of offering a treat. A trick might be a soaped window, or a toilet papered yard, requiring much effort to set right. 1a) in addition one gets into psychological questions of known costs (adults know how much a candy bar costs) versus unknown costs, and the latter may loom much larger in the mind. 2) providing a treat to a happy child is something some adults find fun--so that the "treat" option is not just a lesser cost, but an actual benefit. Both factors (and they are not necessarily exclusive) would tend to lead to more frequent choice of the treat option.
FWIW