1. clock
  2. Evolutionary Conversations...

Evolutionary Conversations...

By clock on June 15, 2006.

A lot of interesting posts appeared over the past day or two concerning evolutionary theory, what evolution is and how it works.

It all started with Jonah Lehrer's article in SEED Magazine on the ideas of Joan Roughgarden:The Gay Animal Kingdom to which PZ Myers responded with Evolution and homosexuality and Jonah responded with agreement: PZ vs. Roughgarden.

I responded with a post in which I linked to my old review, Books: 'Evolution's Rainbow' by Joan Roughgarden, and ended with a minor quip that switched the discussion from homosexuality to the question of units of selection: Sexual Selection is not dead yet!

Razib responded with: Levels of selection: controversies no one cares about? to which Robert Skipper responded with excellent post: Apathy About the Levels of Selection.

Then I rattled Razib (again - he's read them before...we go waaay back!) with two reposts from my old blog, each taking sideways stabs at crude genocentrism: How To Become A Biologist and Lysenko Gets A D-Minus On My Genetics Test.

This gave Razib an idea to ask for a 10-word definition of evolution: Evolution in less than 10 words - give it a shot! John Hawks was the first to respond with Evolution in less than 10 words

RPM did much better: Evolution, the Population Geneticist's Perspective. And Robert Skipper did much, much, much better: 10 Words About Evolution. I left my own definition in the comments on both of these posts. [Update: John Wilkins offers his own interesting definition: Evolution in less than 10 words]

On a somewhat different topic, the new study of evoluiton by hybridization in butterflies was ably explained by Carl Zimmer in Darwin, Meet Frankenstein and John Wilkins in Homoploid speciation - what is it, and why does it matter?

Tags
evolution

More like this

Best Biology posts on A Blog Around The Clock
Reposted, as I needed to add a few of the most recent posts to the list - see under the fold: Now that this blog has won the ResearchBlogging.org Award in the Biology category, people are coming here and looking for biology posts. And on a blog with almost 10,000 posts, they may not be easy to find…
Best Biology posts on A Blog Around The Clock
Now that this blog has won the ResearchBlogging.org Award in the Biology category, people are coming here and looking for biology posts. And on a blog with almost 10,000 posts, they may not be easy to find. So, I put together a collection of posts that I think are decent under the fold. Different…
10 assertions about evolution - responses
I will "house" responses to my 10 assertions about evolution query in this post. So far, only RPM has taken the bait. He asks some interesting questions in regards to the rather vague scope & nature of this query...but this was purposeful. If you examine RPM's list you see that it is…
Evolution in less than 10 words
Razib has proposed an interesting challenge: Define evolution in ten words or less. His definition is this: Differential fitness correlated with heritable variation results in evolution John Hawks' suggestion is this: No evolution means equal offspring for everyone! But both of these focus only on…

Thank you. I was wondering how many people missed the conversation due to it beeing spread over several blogs over two day. Hopefully, this will allow more people to put all the strings together.

Update: John Wilkins offers his own interesting definition

Yeah, but you don't say I'm right, do you? You're supposed to say I'm right...

By John Wilkins (not verified) on 16 Jun 2006 #permalink

Yours is most thought-provoking and I still have to finish thinking about it. There is a distinct possibility that you may be right more than others....