1. clock
  2. Malaria and DDT

Malaria and DDT

By clock on June 8, 2007.

I often blog about malaria because it is a fascinating disease which has to be studied in a highly integrative manner, is a great teaching topic and I could tie it in with my own field.

If you share my fascination, than your Obligatory Reading Of The Day is this post by Bug Girl (via) about the truth about DDT, Rachael Carson, malaria and the wingnut lies about it. Follow the links within it as well for more information.

Tags
medicine
pseudoscience

More like this

Is there any idiot theory UD won't credulously repeat?
Now it's the "Rachel Carson killed millions" nonsense over at Uncommon Descent and it's based upon this WSJ editorial from Dr. Zaramba, the health minister for Uganda. What's really embarrassing is how they link the entire article and it's clear they didn't even read it. BarryA writes: When I got…
No, DDT won't save us from the Zika virus
If there's one thing I've learned over the last decade-plus of blogging about medicine and alternative medicine, it's that any time there is an outbreak or pandemic of infectious disease, there will inevitably follow major conspiracy theories about it. It happened during the H1N1 pandemic in the…
Berlau and insecticide resistance
John Berlau has responded to my post on his accusations that environmentalists were racists. Berlau starts by describing me as: a computer science professor who fancies himself an expert on everything from DDT to climate change. Berlau, I should note, is a journalist with (to my knowledge) no…
Linking without Thinking part 2
Andrew Bolt should have been embarrassed with his unthinking linking, but he is unrepentant: If someone claims to find 24 mistakes in your work and you manage to kind-of defend just three, it might be wiser to actually stay quiet. If you don't actually have the integrity to admit and repent, that…

Thanks for the link! :)

Agnostic,the paper gcochran linked to is discussing South America, not Africa. That is a different vector/parasite/ ecosystem than Africa--and they actually *had* DDT spraying in the 60's, unlike the majority of Africa.

Ultimately, it's an incredibly complex system, and reducing it to a bunch of sound bites in which people who question using DDT are accused of being "a lot more concerned about infinitesimal risks to raptors than heaps of dead babies"(gcochran comment from your link above) is just dishonest.

DDT is just one tool available--it may not be the best tool for ALL situations. You can't just spray the crap out everything that moves and fix the problem. I *wish* it was this simple, but it isn't.