1. clock
  2. Open Access in the developing world - yes, it is a Good.Thing.

Open Access in the developing world - yes, it is a Good.Thing.

By clock on March 2, 2009.

A few days back a paper came out (not OA, sorry), with a keen grasp of the obvious: Open Access is useful for those living in countries where they do not have much access. Duh! Furthermore, those who barely do any science at all, i.e., in the least developed countries, don't cite, so there is no difference between OA and TA there. And yet more, their methodology was fraught with errors galore. I am happy to report that this paper was debunked by several people already - so check them out:

Evans and Reimer greatly underestimate effect of free access

Research highlights from Dr. Obvious: Tracking the citation advantage of open-access publication in the developing world

A Global Perspective On The Open Access Effect

The Evans & Reimer OA Impact Study: A Welter of Misunderstandings

Perils of Press-Release Journalism: NSF, U. Chicago, and Chronicle of Higher Education

Especially those last two by Stevan Harnad are thorough and detailed. Don't believe something just because it has been published!

Also a discussion here.

Tags
open science

More like this

On the Nature of PLoS....
I know that you know that I work for PLoS. So, I know that a lot of you are waiting for me to respond, in some way, to the hatchet-job article by Declan Bucler published in Nature yesterday. Yes, Nature and PLoS are competitors in some sense of the word (though most individual people employed by…
Electronic Publication and the Narrowing of Science and Scholarship. Really?
Electronic Publication and the Narrowing of Science and Scholarship by James A. Evans, ironically behind the paywall, has got a lot of people scratching their heads - it sounds so counter-intuitive, as well as opposite from other pieces of similar research. There is a good discussion on…
Chris Patil (ouroboros) on the Campisi lab's new PLoS Biology paper: cellular senescence, protein secretion, and the aging/cancer paradox
[Point of clarification: I was delighted to use this post to congratulate my friend and blogging colleague, Dr Chris Patil, on his contributions to this paper from the laboratory of Dr Judith Campisi discussed below. As the formal press release notes, "[c]o-authoring the paper with Campisi were…
Reading Diary: Open Access by Peter Suber
Scholars who grew up with the internet are steadily replacing those that grew up without it. Scholars who expect to put everything they write online, who expect to find everything they need online, and who expect unlocked content that they may read, search, link, copy, cut/paste, crawl, print, and…