Obesity, Type 2 Diabetes and The Tragedy of the Common Described in 15 seconds

As a member of the American Diabetes Association, I attended the ADA annual meeting several years ago and heard an inspiring lecture by Prof. Gene Barrett (Univerrsity of Virginia). Dr. Barrett delivered that year's President's Address titled: "The Sheep, the Ostrich, the Ant, Diabetes, and the Tragedy of the Common". {You can read the published article from this address here.}

As Dr. Barrett explained, the "tragedy of the Common" can be described as follows:

"Therein is the tragedy. Each man is locked into a system that compels him to increase his herd without limit - in a world that is limited. Ruin is the destination towards which all men rush - each pursuing his own interest in a society that believes in the freedom of the Commons"

Dr. Barrett emphasized that in addition to technological solutions to our world's epidemic of obesity of type 2 diabetes, we should consider carefully sociological solutions: education, motivation and legislation. I will be writing more about this later, but wanted to share with ScienceBlog readers a compelling "15 second" illustration of the fundamental problem.

Think of the regal lion, king of the Sahara, stalking their prey. The lion's speed and agility are the result of a lifetime of hunting for food. But things have changed recently. Instead of needing to hunt for every scrap of food, the food is delivered to him, while he stretches out for a nap, supine and satisfied, even before feasting. Sound familiar?

More like this

Yesterday, we were putting down media reports on a study that purports that dolphins are not intelligent despite behavioral studies and big brains. Today, NYTimes has a much better article arguing that manatees, despite their small brains, are more intelligent than previously thought. It is a…
Day 2-Sunday The comparative physiology seminars and posters are all being presented today (Monday) and tomorrow. Since there will be a comparative physiology symposium today on fuel utililization and energy metabolism, I decided to attend the symposium held yesterday morning on energy metabolism…
I have immense respect and awe for people with artistic talent. Since I have have absolutely none to speak of, the process of developing a piece of art from sketch to completion (and making it look beautiful) is something that baffles me. Artists who focus on the illustration of specimins, science…
Years ago I proposed a theory (not anywhere in print, just in seminars and talks) that went roughly like this. Humans hunt. Dogs hunt. Prey animals get hunted. Each species (or set of species) has a number of characteristics such as the ability to stalk, track, kill, run away, form herds, etc.…

I don't get it. The tragedy of the commons requires that there be a shared resource that cannot be fully utilized via an equal distribution among all stakeholders. How does that map onto something having to do with type 2 diabetes?

By bob koepp (not verified) on 06 Dec 2010 #permalink

Does this help? According to Dr. Barrett:

âThe Health Care Finance Commonâ

- Increasing sophistication and costs for diagnostic and therapeutics
- An increase in the aged population â the âboomer bubbleâ
- An increase in the prevalence of chronic diseases
- The predicted bankruptcy of the Medicare system now at 2019 (est. 2004)

The metaphor/analogy is still awkward, I thought so too.