Building Our Future: Interview With a Cranky New Jersey Taxpayer

This article was written with Corina Hernandez, a Public Administration major at Kean University. The "college student" is fictional.

On Election Day, New Jersey voters will be asked:

Do you approve the "Building Our Future Bond Act?" This bond act authorizes the state to issue bonds in the aggregate principal of $750 million to provide matching grants to New Jersey's colleges and universities. Money from the grants will be used to build, equip and expand higher education facilities for the purpose of increasing academic capacity.


Cranky taxpayer
: Are you kidding me? New Jersey is already in debt. And you want me to say "Yes" to $750 million to help colleges? Fugetaboutit. What good is a college degree, anyway? I got my job after high school and am doing OK. Well, sort of.

College student: Hold up. That $750 million could help almost 50 colleges and universities. You want to talk about debt? How about an investment that could pay back in one year in increased GDP for the state and create 10,000 new jobs? And what good is a college degree? Don't get me started.

Cranky taxpayer: So. That sounds like a cheap sound bite crafted for election season. I'm sick of it.

College student: Fine. Here it goes. My family came from the Dominican Republic and I'm the first one to go to college. I have to work two jobs just to keep my head above water. I wouldn't be able to study at college if it weren't for the state's support. And get this, cranky taxpayer. A Georgetown University study reported that workers with a bachelor's degree earn 84 percent more during their lifetimes compared to those with a high school diploma. And more education means less unemployment. Unemployment rates are 12 percent for workers with less than a high school dipoma, 9 percent for those with a high school diploma, 7 percent for those with some college education, and 4 percent for those with a bachelor's degree or higher.

Cranky taxpayer: Yeah, sure. That may be true, but I don't want to have to pay for it. Pay for it yourself.

College student: I wish I could. But here's the deal. According to a Governor's Task Force on Higher Education, by 2018, New Jersey will be second only to Massachusetts with jobs that require a bachelor's degree. And most of these jobs will be in areas like healthcare, computer technology, business management and education. Then I can reach a level no one in my family has ever seen before, to support them, and inspire my children. I'll be making more than you, cranky taxpayer. Plus, we all know that no matter who our next president is, I'll be paying more taxes the more successful I am. And one more bonus -- I'll be more happy, and less cranky, than you.

Cranky taxpayer: Good luck with that.

This was originally published at The Huffington Post.

Categories

More like this

I want to note three recent articles about science education. They may be dots worth connecting to each other, or they may not. I welcome your hypotheses, well grounded or tentative. Via Michael Berube: "Women Gaining on Men in Advanced Fields". It seems like we've heard this kind of result…
Last week I pointed to the fact there seem to be a set of private educational institutions whose raison d'être is to feed at the trough of government-backed student loans. Mark Gimein has a follow-up at The Big Money. Here are some bits about the "college" which was sued by the graduate who…
Workforce shortages are a growing problem in the biotech industry. Communities are concerned that a lack of trained workers will either keep companies away or cause companies to move. If companies do have to move, it's likely those jobs might be lost forever, never to return. According to Robert…
(On July 16, 2009, I asked for volunteers with science degrees and non-academic jobs who would be willing to be interviewed about their careers paths, with the goal of providing young scientists with more information about career options beyond the pursuit of a tenure-track faculty job that is too…

Not the public's responsibility to pay for higher education. We already pay for lower education, where does it end? My family emigrated from Italy over 50 years ago and I was the first person to go to college, (community college) then a state college, and I had to sign my name on the line for a loan which I will have to pay back no matter what I do in life (even if I claim bankruptcy). If "college student" wants to go to college, pick a cheaper school, work on obtaining better credit so you can get a loan, and save some money so you can pay for it yourself. We do NOT have a public duty to pay for this and the inflated salaries of college professors (most of whom aren't even available on campus). Do the research, google: is college worth it.

Thanks. Your article made me switch from a 'yes' vote for the "Building Our Future Bond Act" to a 'no' vote. Your manner of argument put quite a distaste in my mouth. Thanks for helping me see the light.

Democracy is great, isn't it? The important thing is that you voted with an informed perspective.