Punkin Chunkin - why work to be wrong?

Here is the deal. Why would you put a lot of effort into explaining something wrong? I just don't get it. Wouldn't it be easier and better to just not say anything? The particular show I am ranting about is the 2008 Punkin Chunkin on Discovery (I think). Fairly ok show, but they should have left the science out. The part that made me speak out was when they were talking about the different types of punkin chunkers. They have:

  • Compressed air
  • Catapult
  • Trebuchet
  • Centrifugal Force Machine

To explain these devices (the physics behind them), the show brought in the big guns. Let's bring in an MIT physics professor that has won a Nobel Prize. That should do it, right? Here is their animation of a centrifugal force machine.

i-9f81b4b2e8469c9eabcc290c0b7b3997-1031090835_00jpg_3_documents_3_total_pages.jpg

As they show it spinning, they freeze on the release point. Here it is:

i-5a811bbae8a6a6ecd2665b5e6f888d13-1031090833_00jpg_3_documents_3_total_pages.jpg

So, if you want it to be "shot" at around 30 degrees, this is where you should release it. Right? No. I don't mean to say this in a bad way, but I think some 8th graders could even see that this is wrong. First, which direction is the pumpkin moving at this instant?

i-d73ba067de8a54835f28f3f736e1b670-1031090833_00jpg_3_documents_3_total_pages_1.jpg

The device is exerting a force on the pumpkin to keep it moving in a circle, when that force is removed, the pumpkin will continue moving in the direction it was moving. To Further prove their point, the show includes this other diagram.

i-67408c30a4b65535549e9a696269f04e-1031090833_01jpg_3_documents_3_total_pages.jpg

I am not sure what they are trying to show. Is that the velocity (no) or maybe the centrifugal force. But the centrifugal force is a fake force if you want to be in the rotating frame of the pumpkin. If you want more about the centrifugal force, here you go.

Ok, one more complaint. Here is basically what the MIT prof said about the centrifugal machine. (If there is a large demand, I will list his name - he doesn't need protecting since he got paid to do the show and he has a nobel prize).

"the basic idea in a centrifugal force machine is to accelerate a body by taking it around a circle many many times. Each time, it gets a little bit faster. When you decided it is fast enough, you somehow release this force...."

Maybe this isn't too bad, but when I saw this, I didn't like it. It seems he is saying there is some type of force stored up as though it were energy. And then that force (energy) is released. Looking back at it, maybe it is ok.

The science in this show was a distraction, but the pumpkin launchers did inspire me. Another punkin chunkin post will come soon.

More like this

This year's episode of Punkin Chunkin is coming up (I think tomorrow). Discovery just showed a teaser commercial with the specifications for one team's machine. If you are not familiar with Punkin Chunkin (World Championship Punkin Chunkin), the basic idea is to project some pumpkins. (note, if…
Image: Chuck. There's nothing festive about a past-its-prime jack-o-lantern accruing mats of vegetable mold in the the driveway. At this weekend's 2006 Punkin' Chunkin' World Championships in Millsboro, Deleware, a few resourceful folks will pronounce a nobler, or at least more spectacular, good…
I already attacked the 2008 Punkin Chunkin Show. So, now I going to give the chunkers some tips. In case you aren't familiar, the Punkin Chunkin contest has teams create devices to launch a pumpkin. They have different categories, but I am going to focus on the air-powered devices. The basic…
In my previous post on launching a pumpkin (punkin chunkin) I essentially just looked at what happens to the pumpkin after it is launched. How fast would you have to shoot it to go 1 mile? The answer seems to be around 1000 mph and they are currently shooting them around 600 mph. The question for…

Given the launch forms of military artillery... compressed air is the way to go given a large enough, high enough pressure, fast enough flow, fast valve setup. No example I have seen has an anywhere near fast enough large bore valve. Most are innocent of gas flow, including 180 degree elbows reservoir to barrel. A thin inner barrel coating of Crisco will work wonders, as would modest rifling re British muskets vs. Kentucky long rifles.

Ballistic pumpkins should be gorged on calcium as they grow to harden their substance. They should also have suppressed polygalacturonase re the Flavr Savr tomato (pCGN4109a and pCGN1436 hybridized antisense RNA) to stay firm when ripened.

The Japanese could kick redneck butt with a modest directed effort.