Did A Celestial Explosion Kill North American Mammals?

tags: , , , ,

Why did huge numbers of large mammals in North America suddenly die out approximately 13,000 years ago? Over the years, there have been plenty of hypotheses proposed, ranging from overhunting and disease to death by freezing. However, another group of scientists have recently proposed a different hypothesis; a large space rock exploding over North America.

Collecting layers of sediment from more than 20 sites across North America, James Kennett, from the University of California in Santa Barbara (UCSB) and his colleagues, found that these sediments contained a variety of unusual materials: tiny spheres of glass and carbon, ultra-small specks of diamond -- known as nanodiamonds -- and the rare element iridium. Iridium especially, was present in amounts that were too high to have come from Earth.

The evidence points to an explosion of an extraterrestrial object of up to 5 kilometers in diameter. According to Kennett's team, this explosion occurred approximately 12,900 years ago. Unfortunately, no crater has been discovered, possibly because it was masked by the Laurentide Ice Sheet, which blanketed thousands of square kilometers of North America during the last Ice Age. Another possibility is that the bolide exploded before it hit the ground. Regardless of where it occurred, this explosion could be the reason for the extinction of several large North American mammals at the end of the last Ice Age.

"All the elephants, including the mastodon and the mammoth, all the ground sloths, including the giant ground sloth -- which, when standing on its hind legs, would have been as big as a mammoth," Kennett said. "All the horses went out, all the North American camels went out. There were large carnivores like the saber-toothed cat and an enormous bear called the short-faced bear."

In addition to killing large mammals, this explosion could also have impacted early humans. The Clovis culture was one of the earliest known human cultures on North America. These hunter-gatherers are known for the Clovis point; a distinctive thin, fluted spearhead, which is regarded as one of the most sophisticated stone tools ever developed. The Clovis culture vanished abruptly and mysteriously from the archaeological record, and was replaced by a variety of different local hunter-gatherer cultures.

The exploding bolide would have caused widespread melting of the North American ice sheet, according to this new hypothesis. The resulting meltwaters would have rushed into the Atlantic Ocean, disrupting its currents. This disruption could have caused the 1,000 year-long Younger Dryas cold spell, which also affected Asia and Europe.

Cited story.

More like this

Around 15,000 years ago, North American was home to a wide menagerie of giant mammals - mammoths and mastodons, giant ground sloths, camels, short-faced bears, American lions, dire wolves, and more. But by 10,000 years ago, these "megafauna" had been wiped out. Thirty-four entire genera went…
A few weeks ago I posted on a paper, Genetic Discontinuity Between Local Hunter-Gatherers and Central Europe's First Farmers.Another one is out in the same vein, Ancient DNA Reveals Lack of Continuity between Neolithic Hunter-Gatherers and Contemporary Scandinavians: The driving force behind the…
A Smilodon fends off vultures at what would later be called the Rancho La Brea tar pits, situated in Los Angeles, California. Painting by Charles R. Knight. The feeding habits of saber-toothed cats have long perplexed scientists. How in the world did these cats kill prey with their almost…
A grizzly bear (the black dot in the middle of the photo) walking near the treeline in Yellowstone's Hayden Valley. The quiet of my evening wildlife watching was suddenly broken by a thick Boston accent. "Oh my gawd! Look! It's a grizz! That's the last animal I needed to see! It's a grizz!" He…

I find possibly more evidence for a volcanic even than a celestial impact.

I would expect to see a NOx signal in the atmosphere due to heating of the atmosphere. There is a positive N2O "artifact" (404 ppb vs 280 ppb) at ~11,500 YBP, and also one at 16,200.

http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/ijlink?linkType=ABST&journalCode=sci&resi…

I would not expect a lot of melting of ice. The fireball is going to be very hot, and so will emit at wavelengths that ice reflects well at. Most of the heat would then be dispated into space. I would think that something that big would leave a big iridium signal in every ice core, yet there hasn't been a report of one. These researchers report no Ir or Pt anomoly in a Greenland ice core.

http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v432/n7020/abs/nature03137.html

I think the lack of an Ir and Pt anomoly makes a large bolide during that time frame unlikely. N2O is suseptible to artifacts from bacteria and dust, and the timing of the N2O artifacts is at the end, not the beginning of the Younger Dryas.