Shame on Spot-Prawn Fascists

There is a reason people are pushing for increased marine protected areas (which currently protect less than 0.1% -- yes, that decimal place is supposed to be there -- of our ocean from fishing). MPAs work. That's why in California they passed legislation ten years ago to create an underwater national park system. Now, finally, the project is underway. But not without some contention. Some fishermen are not too happy about closing areas to their industry. But spot prawn lovers are also sulking.

In the LA Weekly, a food blogger wrote this lede:

Your favorite Santa Barbara spot prawn dish, like Michael Cimarusti's signature salt-roasted ones at his Melrose Avenue restaurant Providence, may be a thing of the past if the most extreme versions of the South Coast Marine Life Protection Act (MLPA) proposals pass.

I know that humans relate to marine wildlife primarily through our appetites but to see it so manifestly in the LA Weekly post makes me wonder if we actually belong to the species Homo boneheadedus. What is wrong with us? Maybe we, especially the California food lover subspecies, need a salt-roasted spot prawn to the eye...

More like this

Myopic spot-prawn lovers might not like the idea of closing some of the oceans to fishing, but California is creating a network of marine protected areas (MPAs) along its coast for one simple reason -- MPAs work. Research by Callum Roberts et al. (2001) published in Science found: a network of five…
This month, National Geographic ran an issue on overfishing. In the article on marine protected areas (MPAs), Blue Haven, shifting baselines is discussed, though not explicitly, by the article's author and Bill Ballantine, the director of the University of Aukland Marine Laboratory in New Zealand…
According to Science Daily, the small-island state of Kiribati just established the world's largest marine protected area (MPA). The Phoenix Islands Protected Area (PIPA) is the size of California, though the article does not provide a map nor does it mention what portion of the MPA will actually…
Rock Wren, Salpinctes obsoletus. (spring song). The photographer writes; [This bird] was scurrying along a wall covered with petroglyphs on the NE side of Chaco Canyon. Perky and hardy little birds, and definitely emblematic of the desert Southwest. Image: Dave Rintoul, KSU. Birds in Science A…

I don't like the lead either, but at least the issue is pretty well addressed in the short post.

There's only so many so many ways you can say "the world will end unless we fix environmental problem X" before people just ignore you.

By Bradley Soule (not verified) on 29 Sep 2009 #permalink

Maybe LA food bloggers should stick to food, and not discussion of environmental issues? I am sure fish and chips was delicious with cod- and look where that got us.

By Rachel Brewton (not verified) on 01 Oct 2009 #permalink

Here's your first mistake: assuming that because they are food connoisseurs, they will care about the creatures they eat.

From a psychological standpoint, it makes very little sense for someone who is all about the food to care for what they're killing and digesting.

Some people manage to enjoy eating things they also care about; those animals probably have some sort of established farming program. I suspect the people whining about spot prawn do not care much about living spot prawn; they will, of course, probably whine more if the spot prawn is no longer available.

By Katharine (not verified) on 07 Oct 2009 #permalink

ome people manage to enjoy eating things they also care about; those animals probably have some sort of established farming program.

What evidence do you have thats not anecdotal that MPA's work? And whats your criteria for working, just less fishing?

By eric hooper (not verified) on 21 Jan 2010 #permalink