Monday Night Mystery

Alright, Sherlock.  What's going on here?

Five points each for the identity of the big round thing, for the insect at the top, and for the insect at the side. Ten points for describing the story.

And a freebie point to anyone who comes up with an idea for what to do with all these points.

This scene was photographed in the fall in southern Illinois. Here are close-ups of the critters:

mystery wasp #1

mystery wasp#2

More like this

Polistes dominula, the European Paper Waspcaptured with an iPhone As an insect guy, the first question I ask about any camera is: Can I shoot bugs with it? To my great disappointment, the answer for most cell phones is no. Cell phone cameras are normally fixed to focus at distances useful for party…
Boundary extension -- misremembering the boundaries of a scene as wider than they really are -- has been observed in adults as old as 84 and children as young as 6. But for kids much younger than 6, the phenomenon becomes quite difficult to study. How do you ask a 6-month-old whether the picture…
Courtesy of the excellent bioephemera's Jess Palmer comes this item of news, which concerns photographs of patients taken at the University of New Mexico Hospital and posted to a website. The photographs were reportedly close-ups of injuries being treated--no faces or patient-identifying features…
tags: Harry Potter, Tales of Beedle the Bard, books, JK Rowling, auction, Sotheby's, [larger view] A Mystery Buyer purchased the only publically-available copy of JK Rowling's latest Harry Potter book, Tales of Beedle the Bard for £1,950,000 (US$3.98 million)! This is far more than…

I am pretty sure it is a Cypinidae and this is an excellent short of emerging young (Kinsey would be proud). It isn't the Oak-apple gall wasp is it? If it is then that round thing is the gall resulting from egg-deposition from an adult.

Wasp number one looks like a live oak gall wasp

the round thing looks like an oak gall

This is how I think the story goes]

The gall was originally formed when a wasp, such as a live oak gall wasp, deposited its eggs under the bark of the tree, triggering the formation of the gall. Those eggs then hatched into a larvae which developed in the gall and fed on the tree. However, this well stocked fortress is a perfect target for other parasitic wasps, such as one or possibly both of those wasps pictured, which would proceed to inject their eggs into the gall, where they would hatch and eat the previous inhabitant. A sort of parasitization of parasites if you will.

By tuckerlancaster (not verified) on 08 Mar 2010 #permalink


By ihateaphids (not verified) on 08 Mar 2010 #permalink

Geez, I can never beat the stampede!

Yes, the object is a gall caused by a cynipid gall wasp. Live oak doesn't occur in Illinois, but it is definitely oak of some kind (perhaps pin). One of those wasps is the cynipid gall maker itself emerging from the gall, while the other I presume is a parasitoid of the cynipid - but I don't know which is which (so I guess no points for me there).

To redeem points, Alex will mention your blog daily for a week.

I'm going to go out on a limb (ha!) and say it's an round bullet gall, not apple...the apple galls (Amphibolips spp.) generally form on leaves, and this one looks like it's on the twig-Disholcaspis quercusglobulus?

The other is an may not actually directly parasitize the original occupant of the gall...the larva could either feed on the gall tissue or it could smother the original occupant of the gall.

I don't know the correct names for many galls, but I agree this one looks like a gall on a twig, apparently on Quercus bicolor.

I look forward to learning the truth about the wasplets...

A gall, a gall wasp and it´s hyperparasitoid.

Oh, well if they're both ovipositing, then they're both parasitic/inquillinous on whatever that gall is. They both look like cynipids to me.

Ok, then, new story:

1. Wasp A (not in the picture) is a gall-maker; its larva lies

within the gall

2. Wasp B (one of those two up there) is an inquiline; it oviposits in the gall

3. Wasp C (the other one of those two up there) is a parasitoid; it oviposits in the eggs/larvae of the inquillinous wasp

As for IDs, fuhgeddaboudit.