Greatest Since When?

Via Arcane Gazebo, a pointer to the Blender list of "The 500 Greatest Songs Since You Were Born." At least, it was a pointer to that article last night-- all Blender links seem to be 404ing this morning, which also means I can't discuss the songs in detail.

That's fine, actually, as the list is very rap-centric, and thus I don't really recognize a lot of the Top 50. That's probably a fair reflection of modern pop music, which just drives home the degree to which I'm out of touch.

My real purpose in posting is to grumble about the fact that the starting date for the list is 1980. Which means the presumptive birth date for people reading stuff on the web is now nine years after my own birth date.

Stupid kids these days, making me feel old...

Tags

More like this

The tagline up at the top of this blog promises "Physics, Politics, and Pop Culture," but unless you count my own photos as pop art, I've been falling down on the last of those. This is largely because, despite being on sabbatical, I've been so busy running after the kids that I don't have much…
I've been thinking off and on all day about the Jon Sobel post I mentioned in the previous post. I think he's got a point, but something about it strikes me as slightly off. To get this out of my system, I'm going to babble about it a bit here, and see if anything coherent emerges. Sobel's jumping-…
It says here in the fine print that my blogging license could be revoked if I fail to offer a public opinion on the Cosmos reboot, which premiered last night. I missed the first couple of minutes-- I had The Pip for bedtime, and he didn't start snoring until 8:58-- but saw most of it in real time.…
It feels a little weird not to be doing a Short Story Club entry, so here's a different sort of pop culture item: Over at EphBlog, my classmate Derek Catsam has decided to break up the carnival of reactionary politics by commenting on great albums, jumping off from Spin's Top 125 of the Last 25…

Stupid kids these days, making me feel old...

You're two years younger than me -- and, just to add insult to injury, I'm a lowly postdoc and you're already on the faculty foodchain.

Quit complainin', whippersnapper. And get off my lawn.

While you're all complaining about the starting date, I'm going to complain that "Hit Me Baby One More Time" is up at #9. Before "You Shook Me All Night Long." Before anything by, say, R.E.M. (who doesn't get on until #79, with "Losing My Religion"). And "Two Princes" isn't even on the list. Pshaw!

By ThePolynomial (not verified) on 11 May 2006 #permalink

I would've commented more on the list, but it was 404ing when I went to write the post. The songs I recognize are a weird mix of big hits and album tracks. I'm sort of puzzled to see "I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man" as the top Prince song, for example-- though it might be my favorite track of his, it wasn't a big hit back in the day.

It's like they couldn't make up their minds whether they wanted to be writing about pop songs, or be record-store dorks pushing obscure stuff you've never heard.

Poly:
for "Two Princes" you'll need to check Blender's list of the "50 Worst Songs Ever." #21 to be precise.

I am four years younger then when this stupid list starts, and I guess I barely know half of these songs. Maybe its just that i grew up listening to way to many of my parents old 60's and 70's records, but there is far too much 2000-2006 rap on that list. Also isn't 500 songs a bit long, why not 12 or 24 depending on the number you could put on a disc. They could at least sell that, sheesh.

Ha, CCP, definitely didn't notice. I suppose I don't mind whitey-whitewhite scatting as much as the next guy.

By ThePolynomial (not verified) on 12 May 2006 #permalink