Race and Cleaning

Kate and I both hate doing housework, so a year or so ago, we broke down and hired a cleaning service. Every other week, they send a crew in to vacuum and dust and clean the bathroom and kitchen, so we don't have to. IT's not a terribly expensive service, and we're happier as a result.

I occasionally have pangs of liberal guilt about this, because it's such a bourgeois thing to do. I had this mental image (aided by the brochure they sent when we signed up) of the cleaners as middle-aged Hispanic women, probably getting paid about six bucks an hour. Which would put me in the position of aiding and abetting the exploitation of the underclass, all because I'm too lazy to vacuum my own damn house.

Of course, I've never actually seen these people, as they generally come when we're at work. Until today, when I was running a little late, and the cleaners showed up just as I was about to leave: two white guys in their 20's. They looked like college students working a summer job.

I'm not sure where this fits in the context of International Blog Against Racism Week, but I thought it was pretty funny.

Tags

More like this

I do it for the toys: OK, it's not like they gave me a robot vacuum cleaner because of the blog, but I spent some of the money I got paid for blogging on this. It helped that there was a talk by Colin Angle of iRobot on campus a while back, talking about the history of the company, as part of the…
Last week's Casual Friday study focused on messes around the home. We identified eight common household messes, and then asked readers how annoying they were, and who cleaned up. An interesting thing happened: for the first time ever, we had significantly more female respondents than male…
I've survived my spring break; now I have my first week back, while my husband tries to survive his. Week of March 17-23 Monday we moved the appliances and all the kitchen stuff back into the kitchen, packed up all my stuff from the previous week, all my husband's stuff for the forthcoming week (…
Classes for the Fall term start next week, which means that things are starting to gear up on campus. We've been sent our class rosters, and lists of new freshman advisees, and have started to have meetings about team-taught courses and department policies and the like. And, of course, the new…

. . . now I feel sexist for being unhappy at the idea of guys vacuuming the bedroom floor, where I forgot to pick up various bits of clothing.

(I don't suppose you thought to ask them what the heck product they use that smells like cinammon, and could they not?)

So you're happy to give work to educated white men, but would hate to hire poor minority women, eh?

I find that the only way to not feel guilty about a cleaning service is to think of it as a cleaning service, rather than as maids. Maids are personal servants, doing the work you're too good to do; a cleaning service is a company you hire to provide you with, well, a service, the same way you get internets and oil changes.

So you're happy to give work to educated white men, but would hate to hire poor minority women, eh?

Based on the note they left with some coupons for cleaning products (presumably the cinnamon-smelling stuff Kate doesn't like), "educated" might be a stretch. Then again, I've seen similar writing from actual college students, so who knows?

Meeting the cleaners didn't change my feelings about the service (which, I agree, is not the same thing as having a maid-- I'd be absolutely paralyzed with guilt over that), it just struck me as funny to have my assumptions exposed that way.

At Jordin's instigation we hired a cleaning service called Renta Yenta. The first group that showed up to clean our house were 20 somthings in doc martens with tats and piercings everywhere. I blinked a lot at first, but they were really good! They eventually left the service and the people we've had since then have been mostly ok but never as good as Sean and Rachel were.

MKK