1. principles
  2. What's the Matter with Wisconsin?

What's the Matter with Wisconsin?

By drorzel on January 4, 2007.

Inside Higher Ed reports on an impressively bad idea from the upper midwest:

"If we can't lure them here, let's tether them here," said Mark O'Connell, executive director of the Wisconsin Counties Association, a lobbying organization, and a member of the Commission on Enhancing the Mission of the Wisconsin Colleges, a group created to advise the network of 13 two-year colleges in the state.The commission, appointed by the chancellor of the University of Wisconsin Colleges in August, submitted a report late last month calling for an investment in new scholarships pegged to residency requirements post-graduation. "If we can't lure people to our state, smart, young people, let's give them education and then require them to stay here a certain number of years," O'Connell said.

I have a 9am lab today (this article, like most of my daytime posts, comes to you via the "schedule posts" feature), so I was lamenting the fact that I wouldn't have time to rant about what a silly idea this is. Happily, though, the Dean Dad did it for me.

Tags
Academia
Economics

More like this

Ineffective alternative medicine is not always harmless
Due to a death in the family, I have to go back into the vaults of the old blog for some more reposts. Regular blogging should resume in a day or two. This particular post first appeared on February 1, 2006. Here's something I wish there was more of, the criminal prosecution of quacks when their…
Naturopathy: When fake doctors cosplay real doctors
Someone yesterday was not very happy with my attitude towards naturopaths, as evidenced in my post yesterday about the death of a young woman named Jade Erick due to intravenous infusion of curcumin by—you guessed it—a naturopath. Amusingly, that someone going by the 'nym of JR said that he or she…
Occupational Health News Roundup
The two-year anniversary of OSHA's proposed silica rule being stuck at the White House Office of Management & Budget (which Celeste wrote about here) attracted some media attention. NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce did an in-depth story on the hazards of airborne silica exposure, which increases the…
I Wonder Why Most Workers Want to Quit Their Jobs....
I can't figure it, myself. By way of driftglass, we come across this report indicating massive employee dissatisfaction: Workers can't wait to dump their employers: 84 percent of respondents to a survey say they plan to actively look for a new job this year. That's up from 60 percent who said they…

the details may be a little off, but the idea doesn't seem that spectacularly bad to me. the uw is an excellent system and i don't see any problem with enticing (not trapping) its graduates to stay.

perhaps a better way of looking at it is this. let's say a student takes out a loan to cover their higher education, as is typical. then for every year spent working in wisconsin, the state pays off a percentage of your loan. is that really so silly?

Hmm... as a Wisconsinite it would be interesting to know if this guy was actually a graduate from the Wisconsin system. I haven't really seen any publicity about this and I think it will never fly - it imposes immediate costs on the state government for no obvious gain, and that would be a no-no here currently.

Where I could see some variation of this would be at the smaller UW campuses: Superior or Platteville, for example, as an incentive to have people go there rather than jumping at the Madison and Milwaukee UW campuses, just to level out admissions.