Shifting Baselines in the Gulf of California

Check out this website (in English as well as Spanish) on shifting baselines in the Gulf of California, Mexico. There are three recently published papers featured, too, each documenting some consquence of the shifting baseline syndrome (and each led by scientist Andrea Saenz-Arroyo).

The first shows that Gulf grouper populations declined long before official statistics were collected. The second shows that, when compared to younger fishermen, older fishermen from the Gulf of California name five time as many species as once abundant but now depleted. The third presents descriptions of the Gulf of California marine ecosystem from travellers during the 16th to 19th centuries.

The website also displays this wonderful pictorial of the shifting baselines syndrome (by Anne Randall and Pier Thiret):

i-535bf1ac4c807726116d071e7561095d-sb_ilustracion_800w.jpg

Incidentally, these papers helped inform Callum Roberts lastest book The Unnatural History of the Sea, which Daniel Pauly said dealt excellently with the shifting baselines syndrome and "should be obligatory reading for all those who think everything is fine."

More like this

Young Mexicans have a warped view of what is 'normal' in the Gulf of California. This was first shown in a marvelous 2005 study on Rapidly shifting environmental baselines among fishers of the Gulf of California where the authors interviewed 108 fishermen. Compared to young fishers, old fishers…
The book The Unnatural History of the Sea by Callum Roberts, a marine ecologist at the University of York in England, is the 2007 shifting baseline story of the year. Roberts pulls together the best historical studies of fisheries, photos, and woebegone descriptions of former marine abundance. A…
I know that the year is far from over, but Loren McClenachan, who works with Jeremy Jackson at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography, has what I believe is the shifting baselines story of 2009. Just to review from the old shifting baselines days, the shifting baselines syndrome implies that…
Since Watson did not have authority, he made use of what he did have: publicity. For those of you who know Paul Watson, founder of Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, you won't be surprised to see this photo and long profile landed a cover story in this week's New Yorker. Not that Paul Watson is…

A picture is worth a thousand words. A series of three is worth a million.

Its time to accept that the youth experiences of the 1960's (a time when brains were under-stimulated and seeking knowledge rather than feeling bombarded by it) are long, long gone.

I saw a seminar once, a decade ago or so, where a guy explained why he believed apples had originally involved to have their seeds dispersed primarily by bears. I can't remember the reasoning now, but it seemed sensible at the time.