Could Dark Matter just be Normal Stuff that’s Dark? (Synopsis)

“When a train goes through a tunnel and it gets dark, you don’t throw away the ticket and jump off. You sit still and trust the engineer.” -Corrie Ten Boom

When you look out into the Universe at distant galaxies, at clusters of galaxies or at the Universe on the largest scales, what you see is the luminous stuff, which is pretty exclusively stars and stellar-related objects.

Image credit: Richard Payne (Arizona Astrophotography), via Image credit: Richard Payne (Arizona Astrophotography), via

But based on what we know about gravitation on those scales, we know there's got to be much more mass than that, most of which doesn't emit light: dark matter. It seems like a great leap to presume that there's a new type of matter out there accounting for these observations.

Image credit: Pearson / Addison Wesley, from J. Scott Shaw at University of Georgia, via Image credit: Pearson / Addison Wesley, from J. Scott Shaw at University of Georgia, via

Could normal, non-luminous matter possibly account for all the dark matter? No, and here's why!

More like this

"There is no dark side in the moon, really. Matter of fact, it's all dark." -Pink Floyd / Gerry O'Driscoll It's been another fantastic week here at Starts With A Bang, where we've taken on a huge diversity of topics and run two fantastic posts from our contributing writers: Brian Koberlein and…
"One mustn't look at the abyss, because there is at the bottom an inexpressible charm which attracts us." -Gustave Flaubert The deepest depths of space, out beyond our atmosphere, our Solar System, and even our galaxy, hold the richness of the great Universe beyond. Stretching for billions of light…
"By now you must know that your father can never be turned from the Dark Side. So will it be with you." -Emperor Palpatine, Return of the Jedi You've heard about dark matter. It's the notion that the Universe is somehow very much different than the small corner of it that we're most familiar with…
“The simple fact of existence, of being aware that you are aware; this to me is the most astounding fact.” -William Hurt There was so much that happened this past week on Starts With A Bang, from eruptions to bad science reporting to black holes and more, that we couldn't help but share so much…

I thought conventional wisdom held that that mass of the Oort cloud was about 450 Earth masses, about that of all the planets, not 300,000 Earth masses i.e. the mass of the Sun. What has changed?

By Ted Lawry (not verified) on 29 Aug 2014 #permalink