Ask Ethan: Does Earth really have a second Moon? (Synopsis)

"You can be the Moon and still be jealous of the stars." -Gary Allen

Earlier this week, NASA announced the discovery of Asteroid 2016 HO3, calling it Earth’s second moon. And it turns out that this is an object in a stable orbit, the same distance from the Sun as the Earth, that can be found revolving around our world at a distance between 38 and 100 times the distance from us to the Moon.

The orbits of all the known Potentially Hazardous Asteroids, as of 2013. This includes asteroids that have been gravitationally captured by the Earth-Sun system. Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech. The orbits of all the known Potentially Hazardous Asteroids, as of 2013. This includes asteroids that have been gravitationally captured by the Earth-Sun system. Image credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech.

But that isn’t exactly the same as having a second Moon! In order to be considered not just a natural satellite but a stable one, you need to remain orbiting your parent world for a long period of time, not just tens, hundreds or thousands of years, like a transient quasi-satellite. Despite its current orbital characteristics, this object is much more akin to the multiple Trojan asteroids orbiting with our world than anything we’d consider moon-like.

A model of the Trojan asteroids around Jupiter, using Celestia. Image credit: Guillermo Abramson, via http://fisica.cab.cnea.gov.ar/estadistica/abramson/celestia/. A model of the Trojan asteroids around Jupiter, using Celestia. Image credit: Guillermo Abramson, via http://fisica.cab.cnea.gov.ar/estadistica/abramson/celestia/.

Go get the full story on all of our so-called “second moons” on this week’s Ask Ethan!

More like this

“If somebody's going to pay money to come see you perform, then it should be something to see.” -Michael Trent The past two weeks at Starts With A Bang have been awesome for all we've covered, even with a (brief) vacation on my part thrown in there. (Don't worry, you'll get the best of it this…
“The moon was like this awesome, romantic, mysterious thing, hanging up there in the sky where you could never reach it, no matter how much you wanted to. But you’re right. Once you’re actually here, it’s just a big, dull rock.” -Futurama Oh, but the big dull rocks are fascinating in their own…
My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nine Pickles. --Children everywhere, up until very recently Taking a look at the new ring discovered around Saturn made me realize something. Most of us don't realize how full of crap our Solar System is. I don't mean planets, or moons, or comets or asteroids…
"Tell me what you feel in your room when the full moon is shining in upon you and your lamp is dying out, and I will tell you how old you are, and I shall know if you are happy." -Henri Frederic Amiel Tonight is a special night, although not for the reasons you may think. Yes, it's just a few days…

“Does Earth Really Have A Second Moon?”

I don’t know how you manage to sleep at night, Ethan,
what with all these “earth-shaking” questions occupying your mind.
(Or do you sleep in the day, and come out only at night? Like … )

But getting closer to home, down-to-earth, so to speak,
do you like theories #1 & #5 best?
They both seem to involve hypotheticals that were literally *earth-shaking*:
http://csep10.phys.utk.edu/astr161/lect/moon/moon_formation.html

By See Noevo (not verified) on 25 Jun 2016 #permalink

See Noevo is a pseudonym for Cyril the Cynic. Take no heed of his cheap jibes. He has felt the need to insult and humiliate people for as long as the web exists.

By Abel Magwitch (not verified) on 26 Jun 2016 #permalink

Apparently Earth hasn't cleared its orbit. We are living on a dwarf planet, I suppose.

No, carl, just because you haven't a bloody clue what you're talking about, this doesn't mean your ignorance is right.