Ask Ethan: Are 'Dark Comets' The Universe's Biggest Threat To Earth? (Synopsis)

“Honestly, if you’re given the choice between Armageddon or tea, you don’t say ‘what kind of tea?” -Neil Gaiman

Between the near-Earth asteroids that orbit close by our planet, and the distant comets that plunge periodically into the inner Solar System, Earth has plenty to be concerned about over the long haul. A slight gravitational nudge to any of those objects could put them on a collision course for our world. Thankfully, we can see them and track them, and calculate exactly how big of a threat they are to us.

Comet Lovejoy, as seen from the International Space Station, poses no threat to Earth. Image credit: NASA / ISS. Comet Lovejoy, as seen from the International Space Station, poses no threat to Earth. Image credit: NASA / ISS.

But what about the centaurs: objects in the vicinity of the four gas giants? Instead of being bright like a comet or close like an asteroid, they’re a combination of dark and distant, making them a difficult class to catalogue and trace. If one of them were headed for us, is there any way to know? One scientist theorizes that these classes of objects -- the ‘dark comets’ of the Universe -- are the biggest threat to Earth.

While asteroids (grey) and Kuiper Belt objects beyond Neptune (blue and orange) are generally considered Earth's greatest threats, the centaurs (green) number over 44,000. Image credit: WilyD at English Wikipedia. While asteroids (grey) and Kuiper Belt objects beyond Neptune (blue and orange) are generally considered Earth's greatest threats, the centaurs (green) number over 44,000. Image credit: WilyD at English Wikipedia.

That’s a nice idea, but something isn’t quite right about it. Can you spot it? Find out on this week’s Ask Ethan!

More like this

My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nine Pickles. --Children everywhere, up until very recently Taking a look at the new ring discovered around Saturn made me realize something. Most of us don't realize how full of crap our Solar System is. I don't mean planets, or moons, or comets or asteroids…
"It is not when truth is dirty, but when it is shallow, that the lover of knowledge is reluctant to step into its waters." -Friedrich Nietzsche Although the innermost planets, from Mercury through Saturn, were known since ancient times, it's only since the advent of the telescope that we've…
"The great oak of Astronomy has been felled, and we are lost without its shadow." -Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, on the passing of Jan Oort In our new semi-regular series, readers from all over the world (and in low-Earth orbit, too, because why not!) are invited to send in their questions and…
"I have announced this star as a comet, but since it is not accompanied by any nebulosity and, further, since its movement is so slow and rather uniform, it has occurred to me several times that it might be something better than a comet. But I have been careful not to advance this supposition to…

We could imagine a manufactured object with very low observables, as observed only from a single easily predicable point, like the earth.
A mirror whose reflection of the sun missed us would be very difficult to see. But, that's obviously not a natural object, if super powerful aliens wanted to surprise us like that, there's not much we could do.

By Omega Centauri (not verified) on 15 Oct 2016 #permalink