Why you can't see the Moon during a total solar eclipse (Synopsis)

"Even though the reason for taking the photographs was science, the result shows the enormous beauty of nature." -Miloslav Druckmuller, eclipse photographer

During those moments of totality, the Sun is eclipsed by a new Moon, with the latter’s shadow falling onto Earth. From within that shadow, the Sun’s disk is blocked entirely, revealing a slew of fainter objects: stars, planets, and the Sun’s corona, all of which cannot normally be seen during the day. Yet one object even brighter than all the stars -- the new Moon -- will remain invisible throughout the eclipse.

The Sun's atmosphere is not confined to the photosphere or even the corona, but rather extends out for millions of miles in space, even under non-flare or ejection conditions. Thanks to the masking technology of the coronagraph, we can view it from either Earth or space. Image credit: NASA's Solar Terrestrial Relations Observatory.

Despite the Moon acting as the ultimate coronagraph, blocking out 100% of the Sun’s light, and despite the full Earth reflecting its light back onto the Moon, you won’t be able to see the lunar surface at all. Why is that? It’s the relative brightness of something very close by: the solar corona. Even though the Sun’s corona is some 400,000 times less bright than the Sun, it’s still ~10,000 times brighter than the new Moon, enough to render it totally invisible to human eyes. It’s like trying to see a firefly an inch away from a shining light bulb, when you’re standing 20 feet away.

Fireflies may give off light and put on a spectacular show, but at only 0.025 lumens apiece, they need to be far away from any other, much brighter light source to be seen. Image credit: Otto Phokus / flickr.

In short: the corona is too close and too bright, and that’s why the Moon is only visible in photographs.

More like this

“Having totality means being capable of following 'what is,' because 'what is' is constantly moving and constantly changing. If one is anchored to a particular view, one will not be able to follow the swift movement of 'what is.'” -Bruce Lee If you’ve never seen a total solar eclipse before, you’ve…
“It will shine still brighter when night is about you. May it be a light to you in dark places, when all other lights go out.” ―Galadriel, LOTR, J.R.R. Tolkien Well, we've been anticipating it for months (or years), but this is our very first time meeting up since the total solar eclipse here at …
"Yes, I am well aware that nature -- or what we call nature: that totality of objects and processes that surrounds us and that alternately creates us and devours us -- is neither our accomplice nor our confidant." -Octavio Paz For most of us heading to the path of totality, we're in for an…
“Girls blush, sometimes, because they are alive, half wishing they were dead to save the shame. The sudden blush devours them, neck and brow; They have drawn too near the fire of life, like gnats, and flare up bodily, wings and all. What then? Who’s sorry for a gnat or girl?” -Elizabeth Barrett…

I'll be near Carbondale for the eclipse. I've purchased the glasses, have the hotel room reservation, and will pack plenty of food and water.

I hope being unable to see the new Moon is the worst problem I have that day!

May good viewing fall upon those who venture out for Monday's grand view.

Why could i not see the Moon prior or after the eclipse? One would think we could see the moon moving toward the sun before covering it.

By jeffery Hogancamp (not verified) on 24 Aug 2017 #permalink

I hate to burst your bubble, but I was able to see the surface of the moon during totality. It was faint, but it was there.

I was near Vienna, IL along the centerline.

In fact, I was surprised by seeing it as all the pictures I've ever seen were of nothing but a featureless black disc.

"One would think we could see the moon moving toward the sun before covering it."

Think about it
1) the sun is VERY BRIGHT, even during partial solar eclipse.
2) normally you see the moon when the sun is reflected from it. But during solar eclipse the moon has the sun behind it, so the face you see has very little illumination (only the suns light reflected from the Earth back to the moon)
3) the constrast is therefore massive. The sun is so bright you have zero chance of seeing the very dim moon.
4) similarly you don't normally see the suns corona (the atmosphere). Its always there, but normally the sun is SO bright you cannot see it, as its much less bright. But during total solar eclipse the sun is hidden, so the corona becomes visible..

I'm no expert at all and don't pretend to be, but the moon is a solid. So therefore if it crosses the path of the sun, in front of, it would definitely block the light and you would be able to see the moon or a black hole. I was outside well before it took place and well after. I saw No moon before OR after the so called eclipse. Things that make you say hmmmm.

By Chris Liggins (not verified) on 30 Aug 2017 #permalink