1. thescian
  2. Surrogate mothers in India

Surrogate mothers in India

By thescian on May 3, 2007.

A BBC News Video I saw yesterday.

A growing number of Indian women are being used as egg donors and surrogate mothers

The motivations are clear. For many childless couples surrogacy is one clear option (the other is adoption). For the poor women who agree to be surrogate mothers, it is a way out of their poverty, a way to provide for their own children. The contentius area is regulation of this apparently fast growing half a billion pounds industry.

An earlier article in Guardian.

However, campaigners in Britain question the ethics of such businesses. "What is missing here is a debate about not protecting the rights of the surrogate mother," says Susan Seenan, of Infertility Network UK. "It does not matter where you are - in the UK, US or India - giving up a child is a terribly emotional issue. We have seen that here in Britain and I am not sure the Indian system has addressed that."

What is being created is a global baby industry that is regulated nationally, leaving loopholes that can be exploited by customers willing to travel, she adds.

The Indian medical research council, which oversees medicine in the country, does not have any guidelines to deal with foreign clients using Indian surrogates. But a study is being prepared to assess the issue.

The wikipedia page on Surrogacy gives a good overview of the issues involved.

Tags
Prime Stream

More like this

"You Should Just Adopt": Is Adoption a Solution to the Population/Environmental Crisis?
A recent email I received was pretty typical - I won't quote it here because the person meant well, but the sum up was this - they laud my decision to adopt, argue that I should have done it earlier, and point out that adoption is the solution to the population crisis. People who want children…
In Vitro Fertilization Connected to Birth Defects -- Again. Problems With Lack of Regulation and Safety Testing in the Infertility Business
The other day, the NY Times ran a story called "Picture Emerging on Genetic Risks of IVF. It reported on a new Centers for Disease Control study that found that children conceived through the most common infertility treatments had a slightly increased risk of several birth defects, including…
Ethics and population.
Back at the end of November, Martin wrote a post on the ethics of overpopulation, in which he offered these assertions: It is unethical for anyone to produce more than two children. (Adoption of orphans, on the other hand, is highly commendable.) It is unethical to limit the availability of…
The science on breast-feeding (and what we ought to do about it).
There's an interesting article in the New York Times about efforts by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services to promote breast-feeding. Proponents of breast-feeding point to quite a lot of science that supports advantages -- for child and mother -- of breast-milk over formula. But there…