GM food: Golden rice will save millions of people from vitamin A deficiency. - Slate Magazine

Finally, after a 12-year delay caused by opponents of genetically modified foods, so-called “golden rice” with vitamin A will be grown in the Philippines. Bu for  8 million kids, the wait was too long.

GM food: Golden rice will save millions of people from vitamin A deficiency. - Slate Magazine.

More like this

The journalist Marc Gunther recently posted a thoughtful article discussing public perceptions of the role of organic agriculture in a future sustainable food system. He found that many consumers believe that there are only two ways to produce food: "The first can be described, depending upon who…
This week, the G20 Agriculture Ministers gathered for their first-ever meeting to discuss potential measures to address price volatility and record high food prices. The key to any long-term solution is acknowledging that we need to empower the very people whose lives are most affected by food…
F. Cunningham gave a great talk today at the ASM 2012 meeting on the discovery of provitamin A synthesis, Vitamin A deficiency and the creation of Golden Rice. Read my twitter stream here.    
Petition | Global scientific community condemns the recent destruction of field trials of Golden Rice in the Philippines | Change.org.

Real humanitarian save children's lives does not involve the rich extorting rights from the disadvantaged, poor, and desperate.

The Slate article is a misleading piece that would never be tolerated if critical of GMO's.

Some flaws include:
- 8 million deaths is an upper range limit,
- The 8M estimate is global, unrelated to the Philippines
- The 8M estimate includes areas where Golden Rice cannot be grown or used.
- No conflict of interest statement accompanies the article, such as the advertisers on Slate who profit from greater include .
- No mention is made that maximizing profit, rather than "saving millions" drives licensing by corporations.
- There appears no mention that using tax money to protect corporate control over food presents troubling analogues to both colonialism and slavery

I would submit that anyone unable to see legitimate problems exist with GMO implementation seems to have significantly impaired judgment.

By Buck Field (not verified) on 23 Feb 2013 #permalink

Real humanitarian efforts to save children’s lives do not involve the rich extorting rights from the disadvantaged, poor, and desperate.

The Slate article is a misleading piece unlikely to be tolerated if critical of GMO’s but with equally flawed arguments.

Some flaws in this piece include:
– 8 million deaths is an upper range limit,
– The 8M estimate is global, unrelated to the Philippines
– The 8M estimate includes areas where Golden Rice cannot be grown or used.
– No conflict of interest statement accompanies the article, such as the advertisers on Slate who profit from greater adoption of GMO's discussed. (more than 20 corporations hold patents relating to the article's topic of GR)
– No mention is made that maximizing profit, rather than “saving millions” drives licensing by corporations.
– There appears no mention that using tax money to protect corporate control over food presents troubling analogues to both colonialism and slavery

I would submit that anyone unable to see that legitimate problems and concerns exist with GMO implementation would seem to have significantly impaired judgment.

By Buck Field (not verified) on 23 Feb 2013 #permalink

Do we know if consumers in the Philippines will want to buy vitamin-A enhanced, orange rice? Whiteness is considered a desirable quality in rice in Asia (and what problems has that caused with nutrition?)
I wish I could find the article I read a while back questioning the usefulness of orange rice; the author considered it a technical fix to a social issue. There are plenty of vitamin A rich vegetables available in the Philippines--an interesting question is why aren't people eating them?

By Jeffrey Rubinoff (not verified) on 13 May 2013 #permalink

You can see the religious level hysteria against GM foods exemplified in the comments here and at other sites. A level of holy purity is required at the expense of lives of children. Notice too the demonization of anyone who opposes their view.

By Michael Babbitt (not verified) on 18 Jun 2013 #permalink