EurekAlert! update

I got my rejection letter from EurekAlert earlier today. Apparently, the wording of the letter is somewhat different from what Hsien Li got a few days back and she has now posted both versions for you to compare.

More like this

tags: embargoed science, embargoes, publishing, MSM, journalism, science writing Image: Orphaned? Embargoes: you either love them or hate them, and I hate them. No, let me rephrase: I despise embargoes. In fact, science story embargoes have been my daily rant for literally years. No, really.…
Journal Nature has published a short article about science blogging. You do not need a subscription to read it - you can find it here. In it, they highlight Top 5 science blogs according to Technorati rankings. Those five are, quite deservingly, Pharyngula, Panda's Thumb, Real Climate, Cosmic…
Unless you've been asleep for the last couple of days, you've probably heard that our government apparently wiretapped a member of Congress a few years back. According to the reports, the National Security Agency captured Representative Jane Harman (D-CA) engaging in a quid-pro-quo agreement with…
I refer you to the book Bad Clowns, by Benjamin Radford. I remember my first bad clown. I was at a Home Bureau event with my mother, and I was probably not in kindergarten yet. Home Bureau was part of the "Ladies Auxiliary" arm of the war effort during WW II, that remained as an organization long…

Hi, I know this may not be the most appropriate post to attach this comment to, but I have a question which might fall in your area of expertise:

Is it known whether Seasonal Affective Disorder is primarily a function of circadian rhythm upset, or is it a function of the decreased light intensity/total insolation in the winter independent of circadian rhythm issues? (Or is more complicated than that)?

I can think of a few experiments to test either one of these hypotheses (e.g., if it's a function of circadian rhythm upset you would expect a higher prevalence and degree of jetlag in SAD sufferers; while if it's a function of total insolation, you would expect something like a tanning booth to ameliorate the condition).

Have any such experiments been done?

By Craig Helfgott (not verified) on 15 Mar 2007 #permalink

It is definitely the effect of daylength on the clock (see this for a simple explanation). Other factors, e.g., light intensity, weather, can to some small extent modify the intensity of SAD.

Thank you for pointing out that article; now that you've mentioned it, I do seem to recall reading it back in December.

A follow-up question: Is it only the RGCs at play here, or could the exposure response of skin to near-UV light also play a role? If you were to set up a UV lamp to go off before dawn, for example, would this have an effect on SAD?

By Craig Helfgott (not verified) on 15 Mar 2007 #permalink