What angle should you throw a football for maximum range?

College football season is coming to an end (I guess technically, the season is over - it is bowl season). Anyway, this is something I wanted to do a long time ago, but I kept getting side tracked. If I don't do it now, I will never do it. Most people know that a ball without air resistance (traditional projectile motion) goes the farthest if you throw it at a 45 degree angle. What if there is air resistance? Why is 45 the best angle without air resistance? What other questions are there?

I posted about projectile motion before - so you might want to start there. When people say "projectile motion", typically, they mean motion of an object only under the influence of a constant gravitational force. This gives an acceleration of -9.8 m/s2 in the vertical direction and zero acceleration in the horizontal direction. I will start with this and maybe I can show that the maximum range occurs at 45 degrees. I will then model this with vpython. Finally I will add air resistance and see what happens. Are you ready?

Projectile Motion - no air resistance

If there is no air resistance, then I can use the kinematic equations for both the x- and y-directions:

i-637890b899f694755819866b854a3f83-projectile-1.jpg

Also, if I always start the time from t = 0 seconds, then I can replace ?t with just t. Note that I am using x and y to represent the position at the end of the time interval. I replaced the vertical acceleration with -g (as is commonly done). So, how find out how far this object will go? First, I will assume it starts and ends at y = 0 meters (on level ground). Also, I will assume that the ball is thrown with an initial speed v0 at and angle ? above the horizontal. This will give the initial x- and y-velocities:

i-e7d03fea8192b58e9a3331661f26eea4-projectile-2.jpg

Since there is no acceleration in the x-direction, the initial x-velocity is the same as the final x-velocity and the same as the velocity anywhere in between. It just doesn't change. So, what else do I know? I know x0 = 0 meters (will I don't know this as much as I choose it to be true) as well as y0 = 0 meters. The final y position is also 0 meters. The final x-position is what I am trying to find. As I discussed previously, the way to solve these projectile problems is to realize that there are actually 2 kinematics problems. A 1-dimensional kinematics problem in x-direction and a 1-D problem in the y-direction. The only thing these two problems have in common is the time. The time it take for the x-motion is the same as the time it takes for the y-motion (because really, it's the same motion). I will have to use the y-motion to solve for the time and then use that time in the x-motion. Here is the y-motion will all the stuff I have said plugged in (forgive me for writing zero with no units - I am too lazy).

i-f822d32e6755fa53e7c7ec2a8af3ddde-solveforty.jpg

Now, I can use this expression for time in the x-motion:

i-5eaebb71274ead368670071728358784-xrange-1.jpg

What does this expression for the final x position mean? Well, first it DOES have the correct units (units of meters). Also, what if I throw the ball at a 90 degree angle (straight up)? If I plug in ? = 90 degrees, sin(90) = 1, but cos(90) = 0. So, the range is 0 meters. Also, if I throw the ball at 0 degrees, then cos(0) = 1, but sin(0) = 0. Don't confuse this with throwing a football completely horizontal, it WILL have a non-zero range. This is because it is not thrown from the ground, but rather some distance (like 1.5 meters) above the ground). In this range calculation, I am neglecting the position above the ground because the ball will approximately be caught at the same level it is thrown. So, do I have enough to answer the question - what is the angle for the maximum range? Well, I could take the derivative of the range function with respect to ? and do a max-min problem but I want this to be accessible to those without calculus. A plot of cos(?)sin(?) from ? shows this:

i-5b50718a110c2ed36bbf68002d15e019-sincos-1.jpg

Also, I can (to further overkill the point) create a plot of the trajectory (x position vs. y position) for a ball thrown at different angles. This is done with vpython.

i-5de69c4cfe43d1057dd56e16380a78b2-trajectories-34.jpg

Here the angle is changed by 5 degrees for each run. Notice that 5 degrees goes the same distance as 85 degrees. This is because sin(5)cos(85) = sin(85)cos(5). Also, notice that the maximum angle does not depend on the initial velocity (magnitude). This can be seen in the above derivation. Ok - this post is longer than I expected. I will break it into two and end here. In part II, I will add air resistance and see what happens.

More like this

Honestly, I was going to add this to my previous post about the jumping car but I didn't because I wanted to finish. So, here it is and more. Actually, I will just make a projectile motion spreadsheet. That way, anytime you want to do a projectile motion problem, you can come here. Maybe this…
If you didn't catch the latest MythBusters (yeah! new episodes), they did something straight from the physics textbooks. Just about every text has this example of shooting a bullet horizontally and dropping a bullet from the same height. The idea is that they should hit the ground at the same…
Here is a quick Apolo Ohno quiz. Which one of these pictures is fake? If you picked picture B - you are probably correct. That is a picture of "Apolo" being catapulted into a pool of slime at the Nickelodeon awards show (click on the link to see the video - I don't think I can embed it). Ok -…
In part I of this post, I talked about the basics of projectile motion with no air resistance. Also in that post, I showed that (without air resistance) the angle to throw a ball for maximum range is 45 degrees. When throwing a football, there is some air resistance this means that 45 degree is…

Rhett,

Beautiful stuff you post here. Have you ever considered to do a "textbook" or at least some kind of tutorial for those of us who want to learn to code in vpython?

I mean, simple stuff because you should't have much time to do it. Just an idea. Some post with the basics.

Keep up with the good work and greetings from Portugal. =)

By Gonçalo (not verified) on 28 Dec 2008 #permalink

I turned to this site to see how far you can throw a football, and I got "Good Will Hunting".

By Jayontheblue (not verified) on 21 Oct 2010 #permalink

This RULEZ and ROX! :)

By marissa bloom (not verified) on 31 Oct 2011 #permalink

Nicholas A.

GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! but i don't uderstand all that Yo=y stuff could you TRY to make it more simple

(DON'T BLAME ME I'M ONLY 10)

But isn't true that if you are throwing from a higher height that you will get better results if you throw at a lower degree?