Stinging Jellyfish and Shifting "Stocks"

Yesterday, from Seafood.com News:

Scientists are criss-crossing the Irish Sea on ferries, counting stinger jellyfish which are blamed for wiping out salmon stocks...Scientists suspect global warming is the principal cause of the jellyfish shoals...The Natural Environment Research Council has given an emergency grant of [$100,000] to launch a study of the jellyfish.

Recall that smack of jellies that killed all 100,000 fish in an Irish Sea salmon farm. But hold up. What's this about "salmon stocks"? The reporter is saying a bunch of salmon trapped in cages with no escape from stinging jellies is a "stock"? Fish farms being confused with wild fish "stocks", profusions of stinging jellies, and warmer waters. All just part of ever shifting baselines

i-cbf569cef5b8dee9233d2fefdbcb1f61-salmon_cages.jpg

Salmon cages: Home to new "stocks" of salmon

More like this

Warmer waters bring wads of jellies. Global warming seems to be nurturing a worldwide explosion of jellyfish, not only allowing greater numbers of jellies to survive through the winter but also heating up north Atlantic waters where conditions are becoming favorable for Mediterranean jellyfish to…
Three shifting baselines to note today: 1) An article in today's New York Times by Andrew Revkin discusses how "scientists are setting baselines to gauge future effects on the seas." The article is a nice summary of some of the latest attempts to document the decline in ocean health even if it's…
...make that baselines. Check out these stories from the last week alone. A perennial favorite: high hopes for hagfish Fishermen on Canada's East Coast are now considering harvesting hagfish and sea cucumber. Once the center of the cod industry, East Coast fishermen have already turned to sea…
Earlier this year supermarkets removed monkfish from their menus admist concerns about depleted populations. Now, thanks to shifting baselines, monkfish is not overfished after all. According to an article at Seafood.com News published on Friday: A new monkfish stock assessment has concluded that…

Your point is well made! A fish in a cage may have no escape but one free in the water would seem to have lots of avenues of escape. I guess the study will reveal if they might consider changing the verbiage.
Dave Briggs :~)

Just somebody playing with the language, obviously.
Farmed fish are more or less "aquatic cattle", right? And cattle are kept in a "stockyard", right? Therefore, farmed salmon must be "stock".
(Not saying I agree with their choice of words, just that the use of the word stock in the sense of "inventory" [of "cattle"] is at least parseable...)

Unfortunately the use of the term "stock" is all too relevant in some cases. Atlantic salmon that have escaped from open net farms have been observed spawning in Pacific streams. Yikes.

By Lucas Brotz (not verified) on 17 Jan 2008 #permalink